Some researchers attribute the bias in favor of identified persons over statistical persons at risk to the concentration of risk that identified victims face. If they are right, and the concentration of risk is the factor underlying the identified person bias, can this bias ever be morally justified? Both consequentialist and nonconsequentialist theorists reasonably disagree about this issue. I argue that there can be a justification of a bias in favor of one identified person at greater risk than one statistical person because the identified person is worse off (I set aside the issue about whether one identified person can be favored in this way over more than one statistical person). Given the very limited scope of the argument and the pervasiveness of ethical disagreement about the justifiability of the bias, procedural justice should be relied on to resolve resulting policy disagreements.