Top-down and bottom-up forces in mammalian herbivore – vegetation systems: an essay review
Author:
- 1 August 2009
- journal article
- Published by Canadian Science Publishing in Botany
- Vol. 87 (8) , 723-739
Abstract
For almost 50 years ecologists have debated why herbivores generally don’t increase in numbers to such levels as to deplete or devastate vegetation. One hypothesis is that herbivore populations are regulated at low densities by predators, and a second hypotheses is that plants are fundamentally poor food for herbivores. This has lead to two main hypotheses about the role of herbivores in structuring vegetation: the “bottom-up” and “top-down” hypotheses. Here I survey the literature, with a focus on field experiments designed to investigate the soil resource – vegetation – mammalian herbivore system, specifically asking five questions about how each trophic level responds to (i) resource addition, (ii) vegetation removal, (iii) herbivore removal or reduction, (iv) herbivore addition, and (v) the interaction of resource levels and herbivory? I use these to develop 12 testable predictions. I document the major areas of research as they relate to these 12 predictions, and use these to evaluate weaknesses and limitations in field methods. There are surprisingly few terrestrial studies that conduct factorial manipulations of multiple nutrients or herbivores, even though it is clear that these are essential. Specifically, I argue that a manipulative experimental approach is the most valuable way to advance our theory and understanding, and I advocate the continued use of long-term factorial field experiments that simultaneously manipulate soil resources levels and herbivory (preferably at multiple levels), repeated in a range of environments in which individual species or functional groups are monitored.Keywords
This publication has 174 references indexed in Scilit:
- Consumer versus resource control of producer diversity depends on ecosystem type and producer community structureProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2007
- Bottom-up and top-down regulation of decomposition in a tropical forestOecologia, 2007
- The Effects of Spatial Scale on Trophic InteractionsEcosystems, 2005
- Diurnal cycle of sparteine production in Lupinus arcticusCanadian Journal of Botany, 2005
- Consumer versus resource control of species diversity and ecosystem functioningNature, 2002
- Multiple approaches to estimating the relative importanceof top-down and bottom-up forces on insect populations:Experiments, life tables, and time-series analysisBasic and Applied Ecology, 2001
- Population dynamics response of Lupinus arcticus to fertilization, clipping, and neighbour removal in the understory of the boreal forestCanadian Journal of Botany, 2000
- The effect and extent of heavy grazing by reindeer in oligotrophic pine heaths in northeastern FennoscandiaEcography, 1996
- Effect of nitrogen input on carbon accumulation of boreal forest soils and ground vegetationForest Ecology and Management, 1995
- Camphor from juvenile white spruce as an antifeedant for snowshoe haresJournal of Chemical Ecology, 1988