At Least et al.: The Semantics of Scalar Modifiers
Authors:
- Bart GeurtsBGBart Geurts
- Rick NouwenRNRick Nouwen
- 1 September 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Language
- Vol. 83 (3) , 533-559
Abstract
On the naive account of scalar modifiers like more than and at least, At least three girls snored is synonymous with More than two girls snored, and both sentences mean that the number of snoring girls exceeded two (the same, mutatis mutandis, for sentences with at most and less/fewer than ). We show that this is false and propose an alternative theory, according to which superlative modifiers ( at least/most ) are quite different from comparative ones ( more/less/fewer than ). Whereas the naive theory is basically right about comparative modifiers, it is wrong about superlative modifiers, which we claim have a MODAL meaning: an utterance of At least three girls snored conveys two things: first, that it is CERTAIN that there was a group of three snoring girls, and second, that more than four girls MAY have snored. We argue that this analysis explains various facts that are problematic for the naive view, which have to do with specificity, distributional differences between superlative and comparative modifiers, differential patterns of inference licensed by these expressions, and the way they interact with various operators, like modals and negation.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Entertaining Alternatives: Disjunctions as ModalsNatural Language Semantics, 2005
- MostLanguage, 2004
- Indefinites and the Type of Sets2004
- Weak readings of indefinites: type-shifting and closureThe Linguistic Review, 2001
- Free Choice Disjunction and Epistemic PossibilityNatural Language Semantics, 2000
- Informativeness, relevance and scalar implicature1998
- A semantic characterization of natural language determinersLinguistics and Philosophy, 1986
- Essays in Logical Semantics1986
- Generalized quantifiers and natural languageLinguistics and Philosophy, 1981