Are foreigners granted leniency? An analysis of drug sentencing in China
- 29 May 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Punishment & Society
- Vol. 28 (5) , 1372-1399
Abstract
Drug crimes are socially and politically constructed phenomena that are frequently embedded in narratives about foreign threats and national security. Yet research on how nationality structures sentencing outcomes, particularly in China, remains limited. Analyzing 2804 first-instance drug crime judgments (2017–2019) from the Peking University Law Database, this study reveals a patterned and stratified relationship between nationality and punishment. Foreign defendants generally receive harsher sentences than Chinese citizens, but this disparity varies across groups. Defendants from certain Asian countries face the most severe penalties, whereas African and European/American defendants often receive comparatively lenient outcomes. These results challenge a simple “alien penalty” account and instead point to a differentiated and crime-contingent mechanism in which national origin intersects with security narratives and stereotypes surrounding transnational drug trafficking. The study advances focal concerns theory beyond Western contexts by demonstrating that nationality operates as a hierarchically structured and situationally activated status cue in judicial decision-making.Keywords
Funding Information
- Macau University of Science and Technology (FRG-24-069-FL)
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Plea Discounts or Trial Penalties? An Empirical Analysis of China’s Plea-Leniency System and Its Impact on SentencingAsian Journal of Criminology, 2025
- Beyond Focal Concerns: A Qualitative Study of Sentencing Decisions in China’s Sociopolitical ContextAsian Journal of Criminology, 2025
- Describing the evolution of three features of China’s drug policy: Regulation, crime and punishment, and rehabilitationInternational Journal of Drug Policy, 2025
- Equality Before the Courts? Studying Citizenship Disparities in Sentencing in CataloniaEuropean Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 2022
- Smuggling of drugs by body packing: Evidence from Chinese sentencing documentsInternational Journal of Drug Policy, 2021
- Paying Money for Freedom: Effects of Monetary Compensation on Sentencing for Criminal Traffic Offenses in ChinaJournal of Quantitative Criminology, 2019
- Trafficking of Myanmar women for forced marriage in ChinaCrime, Law and Social Change, 2019
- The Death Penalty for Foreign Drug Offenders in China: Legal Protection and Equal TreatmentEuropean Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 2018
- Focal Concerns Theory2014
- Race, drug, and criminal sentencing: Hidden effects of the criminal lawJournal of Criminal Justice, 1996