Building Future Information Systems Leaders: The Crucial Role of Problem Scoping in Service-Learning Experiences
Authors:
- Carnegie Mellon UniversityCUCarnegie Mellon University
- Sara MoussawiSMSara Moussawi
- Joseph MertzJMJoseph Mertz
- Jeria QuesenberryJQJeria Quesenberry
- Xiaoying TuXTXiaoying Tu
- Julia PoeppingJPJulia Poepping
- Larry HeimannLHLarry Heimann
- Raja SooriamurthiRSRaja Sooriamurthi
- Divakaran LiginlalDLDivakaran Liginlal
- Christopher KowalskyCKChristopher Kowalsky
- Martin BarrettMBMartin Barrett
- Gabriela Gongora-SvartzmanGGGabriela Gongora-Svartzman
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Association for Information Systems in Communications of the Association for Information Systems
- Vol. 55, 946-977
Abstract
Service-learning presents a unique opportunity to integrate real world experience into information systems (IS) curricula. Problem scoping is the process by which project members define the problem that they need to solve. It is typically not included in IS service-learning courses. We posit that with increasingly complex and ill-defined problems that face IS graduates, acquiring problem scoping skills is essential to help students work with emerging problems in today’s workplace. We ask the following question: in what ways can students learn problem scoping skills in service-learning IS courses? This paper presents findings from a research-driven pedagogy study consisting of pre- and post- scenarios that students considered at the beginning and end of the semester in a service-learning undergraduate IS course. Through a qualitative analysis of students’ responses about the first two steps that they would take in working on the hypothetical projects, we identified thirteen categories and three themes. The emerging themes provide evidence of students' increased focus on problem scoping and context, on the relationship with the client, and on moving away from immediately delving into technical problem solving. Our findings provide significant contributions to the IS literature on service-learning as well as transferable course design principles.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Challenge based learning in higher education– A systematic literature reviewInnovations in Education and Teaching International, 2021
- Challenge-based learning in higher education: an exploratory literature reviewTeaching in Higher Education, 2020
- Design and implementation of a Semester I for mechatronicsInternational Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM), 2019
- Service learning in higher education: a systematic literature reviewAsia Pacific Education Review, 2019
- Twelve tips for implementing effective service learningMedical Teacher, 2017
- Applying challenge-based learning in the (feminist) communication classroom: Positioning students as knowledgeable change agentsCommunication Teacher, 2017
- Closing the gap between business undergraduate education and the organisational environment: A Chilean case study applying experiential learning theoryInnovations in Education and Teaching International, 2017
- Service-learning: In service of whom? A professor of business reflects on resolving an underlying tension in service-learningCogent Education, 2017
- Project-based learning: improving student engagement and performance in the laboratoryAnalytical and Bioanalytical Chemistry, 2012
- Linking design process to customer satisfaction through virtual design of experimentsResearch in Engineering Design, 2006