Using biointelligence to search the cancer genome: an epistemological perspective on knowledge recovery strategies to enable precision medical genomics
- 3 December 2008
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Oncogene
- Vol. 27 (S2) , S58-S66
Abstract
Genomic profiling is beginning to extend beyond the many applications in discovery research toward direct medical applications that hold the promise of more precise and individualized health-care delivery. There are many barriers and challenges that still need to be overcome before ‘Precision Medical Genomics’ can deliver the promise of more informed patient care, not the least of which is the unmet need for a new conceptual framework for recovering, understanding and translating potentially useful information from a single genome. Although a wide spectrum of scientific strategies, bioinformatic approaches, IT tools and knowledge resources have been developed to support discovery research, the interpretive requirements for recovering clinically useful insights from an individual's genome are different in many ways from those of traditional research goals. In this study, we compare and contrast the fundamental conceptual differences that distinguish ‘research’ to discover generalized knowledge from ‘search’ to recover individualized knowledge. We also consider the merits of applying evidence-based medicine and traditional scientific methods when n=1, and consider an alternative perspective based on a translational engineering approach and intelligence for interpreting genomic information from an individual case. Although the general idea of biological intelligence-based knowledge recovery that we introduce here can be broadly applied for personal genomics across many indications in medicine, we make a case that the need for adopting such a paradigm is greatest for supporting the management of complex diseases, and particularly suited for supporting therapeutic decisions in medical oncology. Early concepts for designing and implementing this kind of ‘BioIntelligence’ solution will be discussed. We also review the anticipated challenges of implementing genomic analysis and biological intelligence-based solutions in the practice of medical oncology by discussing some of the related pragmatic considerations for deploying the first generation of a ‘Precision Medical Genomics’ solution that can evolve and improve over time.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cancer Genome Sequencing—An Interim AnalysisCancer Research, 2009
- Molecular Biology and Therapeutics in Musculoskeletal Oncology*Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2009
- Semantic web for integrated network analysis in biomedicineBriefings in Bioinformatics, 2009
- Scaling the walls of discovery: using semantic metadata for integrative problem solvingBriefings in Bioinformatics, 2009
- Clinical Utility of Microarrays: Current Status, Existing Challenges and Future OutlookCurrent Genomics, 2008
- The regulation of direct-to-consumer genetic testsHuman Molecular Genetics, 2008
- On the Epistemological Crisis in GenomicsCurrent Genomics, 2008
- Power analysis for genome-wide association studiesBMC Genomic Data, 2007
- Advancing translational research with the Semantic WebBMC Bioinformatics, 2007
- Major Susceptibility Locus for Prostate Cancer on Chromosome 1 Suggested by a Genome-Wide SearchScience, 1996