This research is a 'must read' for conservation professionals and researchers examining the role of protected areas for resource conservation. The authors use a sophisticated statistical methodology, coupled with a novel data set, to evaluate the behavioural response of fishermen (in terms of spatial effort decisions) to the creation of two marine reserves within the Gulf of Mexico reef-fish fishery. While the formation of a marine reserve does increase local effort in general, there is much heterogeneity in this response. The authors find that the pattern of heterogeneity in fisherman response to marine reserve creation is correlated with that of individual beliefs regarding the efficacy of marine reserves as management tools, an insightful premise that suggests surveys of fishermen, while expensive and time consuming, may be valuable in predicting a posteriori behaviour.