In this paper we describe an automated design critiquing system which generates cost reducing re-design suggestions. The system is a plan-based tool which produces suggestions to relax locating tolerance specifications. The tool is based on the process planner P3 which can make efficient process plans which meet locating tolerance and datum perpendicularity requirements. The process planner is used to construct a manufacturing constraint net which is used to guide the generation of re-design suggestions. This re-design tool allows the designer to identify without an extensive generate and test search, exactly those tolerance groups which influence cost, how much they affect cost, and by how much they need to be changed to decrease cost. It is then up to the designer to decide if the resulting trade-offs between cost and function are worth while, and if the resulting design still meets its intended function.