Because monocalcium phosphate (MCP) is often a superior phosphorus (P) source to diammonium phosphate (DAP) when used at high rates, a short‐term, growth‐chamber experiment was conducted to compare the two P sources. An acid, P‐deficient Lucedale sandy loam (Rhodic Paleudult) was treated with all combinations of five lime rates and four P rates (0, 75, 150, and 300 ppm) as MCP and DAP. Other needed nutrients and a nitrification inhibitor were uniformly added, and a sorghum‐sudangrass hybrid ( Sorghum bicolor × S. sudanensis L.) was grown for 14 days. Soil pH was lower and soil‐solution P and Ca were higher from MCP than DAP at each P rate. Several DAP‐treated soils produced forage yields lower than that predicted from their P levels; the lower yields were positively correlated with lower soil‐solution Ca. The critical ambient Ca level in DAP‐treated soil was significantly lower for plants growing at the rate of 300 ppm P than at that of 150 ppm, possibly because high P levels enhanced the uptake or physiological utilization of Ca.