A case study comparison of objective and subjective evaluation methods of physical qualities in youth soccer players
- 13 June 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Sports Sciences
- Vol. 38 (11-12) , 1304-1312
Abstract
Subjective and objective assessments may be used congruently when making decisions regarding player recruitment in soccer, yet there have been few attempts to examine the level of agreement between these methods. Therefore, we compare levels of agreement between subjective and objective assessments of physical qualities associated with youth soccer performance. In total, 80 male youth soccer players (13.2 ± 1.9 years), and 12 professional coaches volunteered to participate. Players were objectively assessed using five fitness measures: Yo-Yo Intermittent Recovery Test Level 1; Countermovement vertical jump; Functional Movement Screen™; 5/20 m sprint; alongside anthropometric measures. Additionally, coaches subjectively rated each player on the same five physical qualities using 5-point Likert scales. Inter-rater agreement between ratings from lead and assistant coaches was established for each age group. Moreover, Bayesian regression models were fitted to determine how well coach ratings were able to predict fitness test performance. Although inter-rater agreement between lead and assistant coaches was moderate-to-substantial (ω = 0.48–0.68), relationships between coaches subjective rating’s and corresponding fitness test performance were only highly related for the highest and lowest performing players. We suggest that while ratings derived from objective and subjective assessment methods may be related when attempting to differentiate between distinct populations, concerns exist when evaluating homogeneous samples using these methods. Our data highlight the benefits of using both types of measures in the talent identification process.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Physiology of Small-Sided Games Training in FootballSports Medicine, 2011
- Measuring soccer skill performance: a reviewScandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 2011
- Talent Identification in Soccer: The Role of Maturity Status on Physical, Physiological and Technical CharacteristicsInternational Journal of Sports Science & Coaching, 2010
- Discrimination of U-14 Soccer Players by Level and PositionInternational Journal of Sports Medicine, 2010
- Characteristics of youth soccer players who drop out, persist or move upJournal of Sports Sciences, 2009
- The relationship between peak height velocity and physical performance in youth soccer playersJournal of Sports Sciences, 2006
- Maturity-associated variation in sport-specific skills of youth soccer players aged 13 – 15 yearsJournal of Sports Sciences, 2005
- Physiology of SoccerSports Medicine, 2005
- A multidisciplinary approach to talent identification in soccerJournal of Sports Sciences, 2000
- Talent identification and development in soccerJournal of Sports Sciences, 2000