The Complementarity View: Exploring a Continuum in Political—Administrative Relations
Author:
- 24 August 2009
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 69 (5) , 876-888
Abstract
The politics–administration dichotomy has drawn criticism from contemporary public administration scholars largely because of its lack of descriptive accuracy and particular normative inclinations. In their search for an alternative model to the dichotomy, some scholars developed what is widely known today as complementarity. Although this emerging view received an enthusiastic welcome from many scholars and practitioners, more research has yet to be done to address its conceptual and empirical shortcomings. Using survey data collected from a nationwide sample of city managers, this study explores empirical foundations of the complementarity view of the politics–administration relationship. Specifically, the author first identifies a politics–management continuum based on a review of public administration literature on the complementarity view and then analyzes survey data to see whether the relationship between elected officials and public administrators is characterized by complementarity. The results of the analysis generally support the complementarity view, in that the responses of city managers mostly parallel the idea of a continuum in elected official–public administrator relationships, a continuum that moves from politics on one end to management on the other end, with various policy and administration activities in the middle. This paper aims to make a conceptual and empirical contribution to an important question in public administration.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Woodrow Wilson's Ideas About Local Government Reform: A Regime Perspective on the New Push for Citizen Engagement in Public AdministrationAdministration & Society, 2007
- Facilitating Community, Enabling Democracy: New Roles for Local Government ManagersPublic Administration Review, 1999
- Exorcising the ghost of the politics-administration dichotomy: an institutional theory of administration policy makingInternational Journal of Public Administration, 1998
- Beyond Woodrow WilsonAdministration & Society, 1997
- The Bureaucratic Entrepreneur: The Case of City ManagersPublic Administration Review, 1994
- Strategic Planning in Municipal Government: A Tool for Expanding Cooperative Decision Making between Elected and Appointed OfficialsPublic Productivity & Management Review, 1992
- Enhancing Citizen Participation: Panel Designs, Perspectives, and Policy FormationJournal of Policy Analysis and Management, 1991
- Municipal Managers and Policy: A Partial Test of the Svara Dichotomy-Duality ModelPublic Administration Review, 1985
- The Politics-Administration DichotomyMidwest Review of Public Administration, 1975
- Political Ends and Administrative MeansPublic Administration Review, 1943