Long-Term MRR Investment Planning for Water Distribution Networks: A Risk-Weighted, Data-Driven Framework
Preprint
- 25 August 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
Most North American drinking watermains were installed in the 1940s–1960s. A large share of these mains are well past their expected service life, with cast iron disproportionately driving the break rates. Most existing lifecycle costing frameworks, whether deterioration-based asset management models or standard MRR (Maintenance, Rehabilitation, and Replacement) cost tools, are tied to a fixed data level i.e., they are designed for data-rich utilities requiring asset and cost details most smaller utilities rarely hold. Additionally, many existing frameworks omit the effect of discounting which in turn obscures the NPV (Net Present Value) of future expenditure. This paper presents a data-tiered lifecycle cost framework, incorporating power-law non-homogeneous Poisson process break-rate modelling, risk-weighted prioritization, basic and advanced cost-assessment modules, and NPV discounting, to test whether proactive renewal strategies produce lower lifecycle costs than a fix-upon-break approach over 100 years and at what discount rate that advantage disappears. Applied to Kitchener (936 km) and Calgary (5,391 km), lining-heavy proactive strategies lower lifecycle cost by up to 12% and 20% at a 0% discount rate. The savings become negligible near 3% discount rate and reverse above it. Utilities can therefore run the framework on inventory and break records alone and establish whether proactive renewal remains defensible at their own discount rate.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2026-08-25, Preprints
- Published version: Water, 18 (18), 2348.
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ageing underground water pipelines: Time-to-failure models, gaps and future directionsWater Research X, 2025
- Water Main Break Rates in the United States and CanadaJournal AWWA, 2025
- Innovative foresight for water utilities asset management using PRISM softwareUtilities Policy, 2024
- Optimization of Water Distribution Systems Using Genetic Algorithms: A ReviewArchives of Computational Methods in Engineering, 2023
- Development of sustainable water infrastructure: A proper understanding of water pipe failureJournal of Cleaner Production, 2023
- Construction and maintenance of urban underground infrastructure with digital technologiesAutomation in Construction, 2022
- Relationship between environmental factors and water pipe failure: an open access data studySN Applied Sciences, 2020
- Water pipe condition assessment: a hierarchical beta process approach for sparse incident dataMachine Learning, 2013
- Statistical models for the analysis of water distribution system pipe break dataReliability Engineering & System Safety, 2009
- An Analytic Approach to Scheduling Pipe ReplacementJournal AWWA, 1979