Sublethal tree health conditions suppress tree growth across Eastern US forests

Authors:

Abstract
A range of sublethal tree health conditions alter tree structure and tree growth, yet how health conditions rank in their consequences for tree growth and how these effects vary by species remain poorly quantified. Using repeated health assessment and growth measurements for 37,338 trees across four ForestGEO plots in eastern North America we ask which health conditions and syndromes most strongly suppress tree growth and whether species differ in their sensitivity. We summarized health patterns using Principal Coordinates Analysis, and basal area increment was modeled using mixed-effects linear regression models. Two dominant damage gradients emerged from multivariate patterns in tree health conditions. The first indicated crown-level damage, characterized by defoliation, leaf damage, and insect infestation. The second captured compounded damage, in which crown-level damage co-occurred with structural injury such as stem wounds and decay. Both gradients were associated with reduced growth, but compounded damage resulted in a greater reduction in basal area increment in subcanopy trees than crown damage alone (3.7% vs. 6.1%). Growth responses to crown-level damage varied widely among species, whereas responses to compounded damage were more consistently negative across taxa. Species that were most frequently damaged were not necessarily those experiencing the strongest growth suppression, highlighting a distinction between damage prevalence and damage tolerance. Our results demonstrate that sublethal tree health conditions can suppress tree growth in species-specific ways and accounting for the type and combination of health stressors, as well as variation in sensitivity among taxa, may improve assessments of forest vulnerability.