Participants in the ITYC New Awardee Program were asked to respond to three questions in an end-of-workshop reflection: (1) What did you get out of the program? (2) What did you contribute to the program? (3) What advice would you share with the next cohort of new ITYC awardees? Participants expressed a wide variety of benefits from their participation in the program, including the value of a peer community, recognizing common challenges in 2YC projects, gaining practical grant management strategies and project ideas, and building confidence. Participants expressed that they learned more than they contributed; their reflections highlighted how they enriched the workshop through active participation, practical strategies and research, peer problem-solving, and diverse professional and institutional perspectives. Curiosity was also an important contribution, prompting participants to ask questions, listen, and learn from one another. When asked what advice they would give to the next cohort, participants shared both general advice about being a PI and specific advice for getting the most out of a program like the New Awardee Program. Highlights from a synthesis of the 42 participant responses received are presented.