Measuring disability in multiple sclerosis: is the Community Dependency Index an improvement on the Barthel Index?
Authors:
- 1 August 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Multiple Sclerosis Journal
- Vol. 10 (4) , 447-450
Abstract
The Community Dependency Index (CDI) was developed due to concerns that the Barthel Index (BI) was limited as a measure of physical function in community settings. However, no studies have compared the two rating scales within multiple sclerosis (MS). The aim of this study was to determine whether, in a community-based sample of people with MS, the CDI is a better measure than the BI. BI and CDI data were collected from 90 people with MS. Four measurement properties were compared: scaling assumptions (item mean scores, corrected item-total correlations), acceptability (score distributions, floor/ceiling effects), reliability (Cronbach’s alpha) and validity (concurrent, discriminant, group differences, relative validity). Both scales satisfied recommended criteria for scaling assumptions (indicating it was legitimate to report a summed score) and internal consistency reliability (alpha-0.85). The scales were highly correlated (r- 0.96), indicating they measured the same construct. Both scales demonstrated good group differences validity, but the BI was marginally superior. Notable ceiling effects (BI-CDI) were demonstrated for both scales, particularly in those less disabled. This study sample had relatively minor levels of disability, with over 70% still being independently mobile. In this sample of people with MS, the measurement properties of the BI and CDI examined were very similar, suggesting the CDI does not appear to have achieved its goal of better measurement.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- ADAPTATION OF THE MODIFIED BARTHEL INDEX FOR USE IN PHYSICAL MEDICINE AND REHABILITATION IN TURKEYJournal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2000
- Measuring change in disability after inpatient rehabilitation: comparison of the responsiveness of the Barthel Index and the Functional Independence MeasureJournal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 1999
- Standardised Assessment: A Comparison of the Community Dependency Index and the Barthel Index with an Elderly Hip Fracture PopulationBritish Journal of Occupational Therapy, 1998
- Evaluating neurological outcome measures: the bare essentials.Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry, 1996
- Clinical scales for multiple sclerosisJournal of the Neurological Sciences, 1996
- Individual-patient monitoring in clinical practice: are available health status surveys adequate?Quality of Life Research, 1995
- The Community Dependency Index: A Standardised Assessment of Need and Occupational TherapyBritish Journal of Occupational Therapy, 1995
- The MOS 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36)Medical Care, 1993
- The Barthel ADL Index: A standard measure of physical disability?International Disability Studies, 1988
- Coefficient Alpha and the Internal Structure of TestsPsychometrika, 1951