Evaluating the quality of Environmental Impact Assessment Reports (EIARs) for tourism developments in protected areas: The Kruger to Canyons Biosphere case study
Authors:
- 28 June 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal
- Vol. 40 (5) , 384-398
Abstract
There has been little empirical investigation of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) performance towards safeguarding conservation and promoting responsible tourism within protected areas. This paper examines the quality of EIA Reports (EIARs) prepared for tourism developments in the world-renowned Kruger to Canyons (K2C) Biosphere Reserve, one of the largest in Africa. An adapted version of the internationally recognised Lee and Colley report review package was used. The review results indicate that the EIARs are, overall, of satisfactory quality and that the reports provide adequate information to support the incorporation of sustainable and responsible tourism principles in decision-making. However, inadequacies are observed in certain review areas, namely public participation, provision for mitigation and monitoring, and content of non-technical summaries. Notably, the analytical review areas (e.g. impact assessment) perform better than the descriptive ones (e.g. presentation of assessment results), which contrasts with review findings reported in the international literature. This research provides important insights and contributes to advancing review frameworks and to ongoing debates around the potential of EIA to foster environmental protection and sustainability within protected areas.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- A history of the UNESCO Man and the Biosphere Programme in South AfricaSouth African Journal of Science, 2013
- THE PERFORMANCE OF ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT IN THE EXPLOSIVES MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY IN SOUTH AFRICAJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2013
- Walking the sustainability assessment talk — Progressing the practice of environmental impact assessment (EIA)Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 2012
- Performance of environmental impact assessment (EIA) screening in South Africa: a comparative analysis between the 1997 and 2006 EIA regimesSouth African Geographical Journal, 2011
- Benchmarking performance: Environmental impact statements in EgyptEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2011
- A critical review of checklist-based evaluation of environmental impact statementsImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2011
- A review of EIA report quality in the North West province of South AfricaEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2008
- A QUALITY AND EFFECTIVENESS REVIEW PROTOCOL FOR STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT (SEA) IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIESJournal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, 2007
- Quality of environmental impact statements in Portugal and SpainEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2005
- PASTICHE OR POSTICHE? ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT IN SOUTH AFRICASouth African Geographical Journal, 1999