Comparison of direct laryngoscopy and digital intubation with and without bougie assistance in novice learners: A simulation‐based study
- 14 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in AEM Education and Training
- Vol. 9 (3) , e70053
Abstract
Background: Endotracheal (ET) intubation is a common emergency procedure generally done with direct laryngoscopy (DL). Digital intubation (DI), which uses blind finger guidance to manipulate the ET tube, is rarely used but is useful if secretions block the view or a laryngoscope is not available. DI can also be done bougie‐assisted. This study aimed to compare three different approaches to intubation in simulation.Methods: Medical students without prior airway training were invited to participate in this simulation study on an airway manikin. Participants viewed brief instructional videos on three different methods—DL, DI, and bougie‐assisted DI—and performed three attempts with each method in a randomized order. Data were collected for the rate of successful intubations, the timing to intubation, and dental trauma.Results: Fifty‐one medical students performed 459 attempts at intubation on a manikin. On the third attempt, the trachea was successfully intubated in 65% of the attempts using DL, 53% with DI, and 90% with bougie‐assisted DI. At the last attempt, the time to intubation was 35 (±16) s for DL, 28 (±10) s with DI, and 44 (±30) s with bougie‐guided DI. Dental trauma was less frequent with DI.Conclusion: Ninety percent of medical students successfully intubated a manikin on the third attempt when using a bougie to guide DI. A bougie‐guided DI could be more likely to result in successful ET intubation than DL for those without sufficient training.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Digital tracheal intubation and finger palpation to confirm endotracheal tube tip position in neonates: A systematic review and meta‐analysisPediatric Pulmonology, 2021
- Airway Management in Critical IllnessChest, 2020
- First attempt success of video versus direct laryngoscopy for endotracheal intubation by ambulance nurses: a prospective observational studyEuropean Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery, 2020
- Success Rates with Digital Intubation: Comparing Unassisted, Stylet, and Gum-Elastic Bougie TechniquesWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2019
- Defining the learning curve for endotracheal intubation using direct laryngoscopy: A systematic reviewResuscitation, 2016
- The MACOCHA score is feasible to predict intubation failure of nonanesthesiologist intensive care unit traineesJournal of Critical Care, 2015
- Successful Blind Digital Intubation with a Bougie Introducer in a Patient with an Unexpected Difficult AirwayBaylor University Medical Center Proceedings, 2008
- Is digital intubation an option for emergency physicians in definitive airway management?The American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Neonatal laryngoscope intubation and the digital method: A randomized controlled trialThe Journal of Pediatrics, 2006
- Tactile orotracheal intubationAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 1984