Give them what they want or give them what they need? Ideology in the study of leadership
Authors:
- 14 February 2014
- journal article
- point counterpoint
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Organizational Behavior
- Vol. 35 (5) , 622-634
Abstract
Summary: In recent years, a number of new, values‐based, or ideological models focusing on leader behavior have been proposed. These models include authentic, servant, character‐based, ethical, spiritual, and aesthetic leadership. In the present effort, we argue that these models, despite some differences in key dimensions, are tied together by a focus on moral behavior. The available evidence indicates that these models have only modest predictive power with respect to organizational performance criteria. More centrally, we argue that tests of these models are characterized by significant methodological problems with respect to both measurement and control. Moreover, these models suffer from some serious substantive concerns, including the explicit confounding of leadership and morality, discounting of system impacts, inappropriate assumptions about follower needs, and inappropriate scientific inferences. These models also fail to provide viable new approaches for leader development. We conclude that caution must be exercised when these models are employed as a basis for understanding leadership. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 67 references indexed in Scilit:
- An integrative process model of leadership: Examining loci, mechanisms, and event cycles.American Psychologist, 2013
- Strategies for leader cognition: Viewing the glass “half full” and “half empty”The Leadership Quarterly, 2012
- Leadership and emotion management for complex tasks: Different emotions, different strategiesThe Leadership Quarterly, 2012
- Leader Ethical Decision-Making in Organizations: Strategies for SensemakingJournal of Business Ethics, 2012
- Experimentally analyzing the impact of leader positivity on follower positivity and performanceThe Leadership Quarterly, 2011
- RETRACTED: Impact of spiritual leadership on unit performanceThe Leadership Quarterly, 2011
- Antecedents of team potency and team effectiveness: An examination of goal and process clarity and servant leadership.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2011
- A Meta-Analytic Investigation of Business Ethics InstructionJournal of Business Ethics, 2008
- Meta-analysis of assessment center validity.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1987
- The effects of leader—member exchange and job design on productivity and satisfaction: Testing a dual attachment modelOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1982