Gravity models do not explain, and cannot predict, international migration dynamics
Open Access
- 15 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
- Vol. 9 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
The major social and economic impacts of international migration have led to a strong interest in better understanding the drivers of cross-border movement. Quantitative models have sought to explain global migration patterns in terms of economic, social, climatic, and other variables, and future projections of these variables are increasingly being used to forecast international migration flows. An important implicit assumption in the most widely used class of these approaches, so-called gravity models, is that their parameterisation based on panel data enables them to describe the effects of predictor variables on migration flows across both space and time, i.e., that they explain flow variation both across country pairs at a given time and across time for a given country pair. Here we show that this assumption does not hold. Whilst gravity models describe spatial patterns of international migration very well, they fail to capture even basic temporal dynamics, indeed, often worse than even the time-invariant average of the historical flows. We show that standard validation techniques have been unable to detect this important limitation of gravity models due to the different orders of magnitude of migration flows across spatial corridors, on the one hand, and over time, on the other hand. Our analysis suggests that gravity-model-based inferences about the effects that certain variables have had, or will have, on international migration over time may in reality represent statistical artefacts rather than true mechanisms. We argue that future predictions based on gravity models lack statistical support and that, in its current form, this class of models is not suited for informing policy makers about migration trajectories in the coming years and decades.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do climate variations explain bilateral migration? A gravity model analysisIZA Journal of Development and Migration, 2015
- Does development reduce migration?2014
- Political Effects of International MigrationAnnual Review of Political Science, 2014
- Developing a comprehensive time series of GDP per capita for 210 countries from 1950 to 2015Population Health Metrics, 2012
- Cultural barriers in migration between OECD countriesJournal of Population Economics, 2011
- Where on Earth is Everybody? The Evolution of Global Bilateral Migration 1960–2000The World Bank Economic Review, 2011
- Dynamic Decision Behavior2010
- Does Environmental Degradation Influence Migration? Emigration to Developed Countries in the Late 1980s and 1990s*Social Science Quarterly, 2009
- International migration beyond gravity: A statistical model for use in population projectionsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2008
- Federal Republic of Germany1988