The Differential Role of Comprehension and Production Practice
Authors:
- 1 December 1996
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Language Learning
- Vol. 46 (4) , 613-642
Abstract
This article presents a replication of experiments by VanPatten and Cadierno (1993a, 1993b), which found that input practice is better than output practice for comprehension skills and no worse than output practice for production skills in a second language (Spanish). We argue that VanPatten and Cadierno's findings are at variance with predictions of skill acquisition theory, and that their results may be due to the specific second language structures used as well as to some imperfections in their research design. Our results with 82 first‐year Spanish as a second language students indicate that the relative effectiveness of production versus comprehension practice depends on the morphosyntactic complexity of the structure in question as well as on the delay between practice and testing. The findings basically reflect the predictions of skill acquisition theory that input practice is better for comprehension skills, and output practice for production skills, but these patterns are obscured when both testing time and the morphosyntactic nature of the structure in question favor one skill or the other.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning Simple and Complex Second Language Rules Under Implicit, Incidental, Rule-Search, and Instructed ConditionsStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1996
- Learning Second Language Grammar RulesStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1995
- Cognitive Factors in Learning about Structured SequencesStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1994
- Acquisition of procedural skills from examples.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 1994
- Rules and instances in foreign language learning: Interactions of explicit and implicit knowledgeThe European Journal of Cognitive Psychology, 1993
- Explicit Instruction and Input ProcessingStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1993
- The Structural Syllabus and Second Language AcquisitionTESOL Quarterly, 1993
- Psychological Mechanisms Underlying Second Language FluencyStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1992
- Acquisition of cognitive skill.Psychological Review, 1982
- Controlled and automatic human information processing: I. Detection, search, and attention.Psychological Review, 1977