Happy ever after in the quasi-market place? The dowry logic of active labour policy in the Lombardy Region
Authors:
- 12 October 2015
- journal article
- case report
- Published by Emerald Publishing in International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy
- Vol. 35 (11/12) , 812-827
Abstract
Purpose: – The dote system is the most recent and only way to finance and deliver services in the training and labour policy field in Lombardy (Italy), strengthening the regional quasi-market approach. The purpose of this paper is to analyse its logic and highlight the implications for the policy system.Design/methodology/approach: – Qualitative case-study including preliminary documentation, analysis of administrative data, in-depth interviews with stakeholders and practitioners.Findings: – The dote system is based on a strongly pre-structured and pure performance logic. It predefines forms, ways and steps towards people’s “autonomy”, further categorising the policy system and establishing a combination of individualisation without personalisation. The strict regulation makes it difficult to design accessible, high-quality and tailor-made interventions. Dote could represent an interesting innovation for high-profile measures, but as a universal equivalent it often fails to match the needs of people and the labour market.Research limitations/implications: – The self-funded research is limited to a regional context, analysed against the background of European welfare transformations. Greater effort in qualitative research could improve the knowledge about the implications of NPM and quasi-markets.Practical implications: – Regional centralism is strengthened; local authorities and private bodies are excluded from planning; freedom of choice is limited. A marriage of convenience between providers and users increases the level of stress and the dispersion of resources.Originality/value: – Dote is a particular experiment in the panorama of activation. It works in a unique way, impacting on governance and activation modes. The paper is addressed to researchers, practitioners and policy makers interested in gaining better understanding of the implications of quasi-markets and NPM.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- In the shadow of legalism: understanding community participation in an overly bureaucratic contextCritical Policy Studies, 2014
- Interpreting the marketization of employment services in Great Britain and DenmarkJournal of European Social Policy, 2014
- Varieties of Market Competition in Public Employment Services – A Comparison of the Emergence and Evolution of the New System in Australia, the Netherlands and BelgiumSocial Policy & Administration, 2014
- Governance reforms and their impacts on the effects of activation policiesInternational Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 2012
- The diversity of activation markets in EuropeInternational Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 2012
- ‘Selective Flexicurity’ in Segmented Labour Markets: The Case of Italian ‘Mid-Siders’Journal of Social Policy, 2010
- Activation policies and organisational innovation: the added value of the capability approachInternational Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 2009
- The Provision of Income Protection and Activation Services for the Unemployed in ‘Active’ Welfare States. An International ComparisonJournal of Social Policy, 2009
- NPM and beyond — structure, culture and demographyInternational Review of Administrative Sciences, 2008
- Quasi-Markets in Employment Policy: Do They Deliver on Promises?Social Policy and Society, 2008