Null subjects: a reanalysis of the data
Author:
- Melvyn Douglas ColeMCMelvyn Douglas Cole
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Linguistics
- Vol. 47 (3) , 559-587
Abstract
In the face of problems with previous syntactic theories, this article establishes a new concept relating to the incidence of null thematic pronouns, focusing on null thematic subjects. The data indicate that, in rich agreement languages with null subjects, prima facie, recovery of such subjects is achieved first by reference to discrete agreement and, if this fails, by reference to an antecedent in context. Subsequently, preferred interpretations are resorted to and then overt pronouns. The argument is developed to show that every language has its point of morphological maximality. This is the maximum point up to which identifying subject verb agreement can occur in a language and this level of verbal agreement must be present for thematic subjects to be null. This point is scalar, being represented by morphology for gender, person and number in Tarifit, for person and number in Spanish, for person in Bengal and null morphology in Chinese. A further necessary feature for thematic null subjects to occur is that an antecedent in context completes their recovery. Whether this occurs or not is put down to the contextual weakness and strength of languages. This theory has the consequence that the licensing of thematic subjects is redundant and that null expletive subjects need to be treated as a separate empty category.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Radical Pro Drop and the Morphology of PronounsLinguistic Inquiry, 2007
- Is There a Little Pro? Evidence from FinnishLinguistic Inquiry, 2005
- Parametrizing Agr: Word Order, V-Movement and Epp-CheckingNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1998
- Interpreting anaphoric expressions: a cognitive versus a pragmatic approachJournal of Linguistics, 1994
- Argument-drop in old IcelandicLingua, 1993
- On Null Subjects and Null ArgumentsCanadian Journal of Linguistics/Revue canadienne de linguistique, 1993
- Referring and accessibilityJournal of Linguistics, 1988
- JAPANESE AS A PRO LANGUAGEThe Linguistic Review, 1987
- Topic Structures in ChineseLanguage, 1985
- Agreement vs. Incorporation in BretonNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1984