Drawing the Line Between Essential and Nonessential Interventions on Intersex Characteristics With European Health Care Professionals
Open Access
- 11 November 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Review of General Psychology
- Vol. 25 (1) , 101-114
Abstract
Human rights statements on intersex characteristics distinguish legitimate “medically necessary” interventions from illegitimate normalizing ones. Ironically, this binary classification seems partially grounded in knowledge of anatomy and medical interventions; the very expertise that human rights statements challenge. Here, 23 European health professionals from specialist “disorder of sex development” (DSD) multidisciplinary teams located medical interventions on a continuum ranging from “medically essential” to nonessential poles. They explained their answers. Participants mostly described interventions on penile/scrotal, clitoral/labial, vaginal, and gonadal anatomy whose essential character was only partially grounded in anatomical variation and diagnoses. To explain what was medically necessary, health care professionals drew on lay understandings of child development, parental distress, collective opposition to medicalization, patients “coping” abilities, and patients’ own choices. Concepts of “medical necessity” were grounded in a hybrid ontology of patients with intersex traits as both physical bodies and as phenomenological subjects. Challenges to medical expertise on human rights grounds are well warranted but presume a bounded and well-grounded category of “medically necessary” intervention that is discursively flexible. Psychologists’ long-standing neglect of people with intersex characteristics, and the marginalization of clinical psychologists in DSD teams, may contribute to the construction of some controversial interventions as medically necessary.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- What is Epistemological Violence in the Empirical Social Sciences?Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2010
- Ethical principles and recommendations for the medical management of differences of sex development (DSD)/intersex in children and adolescentsEuropean Journal of Pediatrics, 2009
- Consequences of the Chicago consensus on disorders of sex development (DSD): current practices in EuropeArchives of Disease in Childhood, 2009
- A Universal Model of Diagnostic ReasoningAcademic Medicine, 2009
- `But We Have to Do Something': Surgical `Correction' of Atypical GenitaliaBody & Society, 2008
- Using thematic analysis in psychologyQualitative Research in Psychology, 2006
- Fear of devaluation: Understanding the experience of intersexed women with androgen insensitivity syndromeBritish Journal of Health Psychology, 2004
- Common-Sense Psychology and Scientific PsychologyAnnual Review of Psychology, 1992
- The Medical Construction of Gender: Case Management of Intersexed InfantsSigns: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 1990
- Norm theory: Comparing reality to its alternatives.Psychological Review, 1986