Public preferences for allocating absolute scarce critical healthcare resources during the COVID-19 pandemic
Author:
- 25 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Health Organization and Management
- Vol. 35 (8) , 964-986
Abstract
Purpose: This paper aims to investigate the Portuguese general public views regarding the criteria that should guide critical COVID-19 patients to receive medical devices (ventilators and IUC beds) during the current pandemic context. Based on rationing principles and protocols proposed in ethical and medical literature the authors explore how Portuguese general public evaluates the fairness of five allocation principles: “prognosis”, “severity of health condition”, “patients age”, “instrumental value” (frontline healthcare professionals should be prioritized during the pandemic) and “lottery”.Design/methodology/approach: An online questionnaire was used to collect data from a sample of 586 Portuguese citizens. Descriptive statistics and non-parametric tests were used to define a hierarchy of prioritization criteria and to test for the association between respondents support to them and their socio-demographic and health characteristics.Findings: Respondents gave top priority to prognosis when faced with absolute scarcity, followed closely by the severity of health condition, patient’s age with instrumental value receiving lowest support, on average. However, when the age of the patients was confronted with survival, younger-first principle prevailed over recovery. In a pandemic context, lottery was considered the least fair allocation method. The findings suggest that respondents’ opinions are aligned with those of ethicists but are partially in disagreement with the protocol suggested for Portugal.Originality/value: This study represents the first attempt to elicit public attitudes towards distributive criteria during a pandemic and, therefore, in a real context where the perception is that life and death decisions have to be made.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Relevance of Personal Characteristics in Allocating Health Care Resources—Controversial Preferences of Laypersons with Different Educational BackgroundsInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2012
- Complete Lives in the BalanceThe American Journal of Bioethics, 2010
- Moral disagreement and procedural justice: Moral mandates as constraints to voice effectsAustralian Journal of Psychology, 2009
- Criteria for the Allocation of Medical Resources: Citizens' PerspectivesJournal of Applied Biobehavioral Research, 2007
- Who Should Get Influenza Vaccine When Not All Can?Science, 2006
- Responsibility, fairness and rationing in health careHealth Policy, 2006
- Responsibility in health care: a liberal egalitarian approach: Table 1Journal of Medical Ethics, 2005
- Justice Between the Young and the OldPhilosophy & Public Affairs, 2001
- Value elicitation: Is there anything in there?American Psychologist, 1991
- Selecting People RandomlyEthics, 1984