Autonomy, liberalism and advance care planning.
Authors:
- P A SingerPSP A Singer
Open Access
- 1 December 1999
- journal article
- review article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 25 (6) , 522-527
Abstract
The justification for advance directives is grounded in the notion that they extend patient autonomy into future states of incompetency through patient participation in decision making about end-of-life care. Four objections challenge the necessity and sufficiency of individual autonomy, perceived to be a defining feature of liberal philosophical theory, as a basis of advance care planning. These objections are that the liberal concept of autonomy (i) implies a misconception of the individual self, (ii) entails the denial of values of social justice, (iii) does not account for justifiable acts of paternalism, and (iv) does not account for the importance of personal relationships in the advance care planning process. The last objection is especially pertinent in light of recent empirical research highlighting the importance of personal relationships in advance care planning. This article examines these four objections to autonomy, and the liberal theoretical framework with which it is associated, in order to re-evaluate the philosophical basis of advance care planning. We argue that liberal autonomy (i) is not a misconceived concept as critics assume, (ii) does not entail the denial of values of social justice, (iii) can account for justifiable acts of paternalism, though it (iv) is not the best account of the value of personal relationships that arise in advance care planning. In conclusion, we suggest that liberalism is a necessary component of a theoretical framework for advance care planning but that it needs to be supplemented with theories that focus explicitly on the significance of personal relationships.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- A New Model of Advance Care PlanningArchives of internal medicine (1960), 1999
- Political LiberalismHarvard Law Review, 1994
- Rationing in The Netherlands: The liberal and the communitarian perspectiveHealth Care Analysis, 1993
- The Patient as Citizen and ConsumerProfessional Ethics, A Multidisciplinary Journal, 1993
- Attributes of tinnitus associated with the temporomandibular joint syndromeEuropean Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, 1992
- Trumping Advance DirectivesHastings Center Report, 1991
- Advance Directives for Medical Care — A Case for Greater UseNew England Journal of Medicine, 1991
- Autonomy and the Common WealHastings Center Report, 1991
- What about the Family?Hastings Center Report, 1990
- Harm to Self: The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law, Vol. 3Law and Philosophy, 1988