Trust, Autonomy, and Teaching Dynamics in Robotic Surgery: A Mixed Methods Study
Preprint
- 28 October 2024
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
Purpose Compared to open or laparoscopic surgery, the configurational relationship between trainer and trainee in robotic surgery reduces face-to-face interaction and ability to directly co-manipulate the surgical field. To elucidate the impact of this environment on surgical training dynamics, we conducted a mixed-methods study examining dyadic trust, autonomy, teaching, communication, and feedback in robotic surgery. Methods Robotic procedures performed on a dual console system at a single academic center were included. Trainee console operative time, representing autonomy, was extracted from the robotic system. Bidirectional trust was measured via a modified Leader Member Exchange (mLMX) questionnaire at the end of each case. Correlation between autonomy and trust was analyzed utilizing Pearson’s coefficient. Procedures were video- and audio-recorded, capturing both endoscopic view and a broad view of the operating consoles with trainer/trainee interactions. Two researchers performed thematic analysis of the synchronized video and transcribed audio. Results Nine robotic procedures in colorectal, general surgery, urology, and thoracic surgery were included. Trainee console time was directly correlated with average trainer mLMX trust scores (r=0.54) but not trainee scores (r=-0.19). Average trainer mLMX trust score was 4.08 vs. 3.16 (p=0.038) for trainees with >50% vs. <50% console time; trainee mLMX was not significantly different between the same groups (p=0.74). Thematic analysis revealed major themes of effective teaching techniques, feedback “escalation,” and trust-fostering behavioral strategies. Conclusion Higher trainer trust is associated with higher resident autonomy, and trainers/trainees can use specific strategies for teaching, feedback, and fostering trust in the robotic operating room. These findings may improve communication and trainee autonomy in the robotic operating room, and inform future robotic surgical educational curricula.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Expertise in perception during robotic surgery (ExPeRtS): What we see and what we sayThe American Journal of Surgery, 2022
- Enhancing robotic efficiency through the eyes of robotic surgeons: sub-analysis of the expertise in perception during robotic surgery (ExPeRtS) studySurgical Endoscopy, 2022
- The evolution of the general surgery resident operative case experience in the era of robotic surgerySurgical Endoscopy, 2022
- Trends in the Adoption of Robotic Surgery for Common Surgical ProceduresJAMA Network Open, 2020
- Teaching in the robotic environment: Use of alternative approaches to guide operative instructionThe American Journal of Surgery, 2020
- Association of Faculty Entrustment With Resident Autonomy in the Operating RoomJAMA Surgery, 2018
- Use of Entrustable Professional Activities in the Assessment of Surgical Resident CompetencyJAMA Surgery, 2018
- Entrustment of General Surgery Residents in the Operating Room: Factors Contributing to Provision of Resident AutonomyJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2014
- Participation of Surgical Residents in Operations: Challenging a Common ClassificationWorld Journal of Surgery, 2012
- Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years: Applying a multi-level multi-domain perspectiveThe Leadership Quarterly, 1995