Abstract
This experiment was conducted to compare total collection (TC) and index method (IM), including Cr2O3, TiO2, and AIA, for determining the energy values of full fat soybean (FFS) using the regression method. Twenty-four barrows with an average initial BW of 20 kg were assigned to 3 diets in a randomized complete block design. The 3 diets consisted of a corn–soybean meal reference diet (RD) and the RD + 75 or 150 g/kg FFS, and all diets contained 3 index markers (5 g/kg Cr2O3, 5 g/kg TiO2, and 20 g/kg AIA). Each diet was fed to 8 barrows in individual metabolism crates for a 5-d acclimation followed by a 5-d total collection of feces and urine separately. All data were analyzed as split-plot experiments, where the FFS level was the main-plot factor and measurement method including TC or IM with different markers was the split-plot factor. Results showed that the fecal marker recovery was 90.0, 90.9, and 93.3% for TiO2, Cr2O3, and AIA, respectively, when compared with total collection. The substitution of FFS linearly reduced (P < 0.05) both dietary DE and ME. With the increase of FFS level, the dietary DE was linearly decreased based on TC, AIA, and TiO2 measurements, but not for Cr2O3, resulting in an FFS level by measurement method for dietary DE (P = 0.056). The results also showed that the determined dietary DE was lower using TiO2 compared with TC, Cr2O3, and AIA (P < 0.05). And the dietary ME determined by TiO2 was lower than TC and AIA (P < 0.05) but similar to Cr2O3. The energy value of FFS was determined by the regression method. The TC-derived DE and ME of FFS were 4,131 and 3,873 kcal/kg, respectively. The DE and ME of FFS were 4,072 and 3,814 kcal/kg DM, respectively, using Cr2O3; 3,935 and 3,867 kcal/kg DM, respectively, using TiO2; or 3,991 and 3,734 kcal/kg DM, respectively, using AIA. The DE of FFS using TC method was not different from those obtained from Cr2O3 and AIA but higher than the DE value obtained from TiO2 (P < 0.05). In conclusion, the IM is as robust as TC to derive DE of FFS using the regression method, but the accuracy may be dependent on the marker. Copyright © 2017. American Society of Animal Science .