Prestige or Perish: Publishing Decisions in Academic Archaeology
Open Access
- 1 October 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 86 (4) , 669-695
Abstract
Success in academic archaeology is strongly influenced by the publication of peer-reviewed articles. Despite the importance of such articles, minimal research has explicitly examined the factors influencing publishing decisions in archaeology. In order to better understand the landscape of archaeological publishing, we distributed a short survey that solicited basic professional and demographic information before asking respondents to (1) identify journals that publish important archaeological research, (2) identify journals that people who read archaeological academic CVs value most highly, and (3) rank the factors that affected their decisions about where to submit an article for publication. Our results from 274 respondents generated a list of 167 individual journal titles. Prestige was viewed as the most important factor that affected publishing decisions, followed by audience and open access considerations. There was no relationship between respondent-generated journal rankings and SCImago Journal Ranks (SJR), but there were significant differences in average SJR by gender and career stage. Responses showed consensus on only a small number of highly ranked archaeology and science-subject journals, with little agreement on the importance of most other journals. We conclude by highlighting the areas of disciplinary consensus and divergence revealed by the survey and by discussing how implicit prestige hierarchies permeate academic archaeology.Keywords
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Library and Information Science Journal Prestige as Assessed by Library and Information Science FacultyThe Library Quarterly, 2013
- The h‐index: a broad review of a new bibliometric indicatorJournal of Documentation, 2010
- Electronic journals and changes in scholarly article seeking and reading patternsAslib Proceedings, 2009
- Dual Anthropology Career Couples: Different Strategies and Different Success RatesArchaeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association, 2008
- Comparison of SCImago journal rank indicator with journal impact factorThe FASEB Journal, 2008
- Publishing Archaeology in Science and Scientific American, 1940–2003American Antiquity, 2005
- The Intersections of Identity and Politics in ArchaeologyAnnual Review of Anthropology, 2002
- Gendered Citation Practices inAmerican Antiquityand Other Archaeology JournalsAmerican Antiquity, 2002
- Women, Archeology, and the National Science Foundation: An Analysis of Fiscal Year 1989 DataArchaeological Papers of the American Anthropological Association, 1994
- Socio-Politics and the Woman-at-Home IdeologyAmerican Antiquity, 1985