Abstract
Professional internships constitute a privileged space for articulation between universities and educational establishments; however, their evaluation has traditionally focused on the learning of the future teacher, paying less attention to the learning and transformation processes that interaction can generate in collaborating teachers, universities and schools. The purpose of this study was to analyze how the literature has conceptualized and evaluated bidirectionality in professional practices of initial teacher training, identifying its conceptual evolution, the mechanisms by which it is produced, and the evidence used to recognize its contributions and impacts. A systematic review of 71 studies published between 1990 and 2026 was conducted. The analysis shows an evolution from models focused on supervision and knowledge transfer to perspectives based on functional reciprocity, mutual learning, knowledge co-construction and institutional transformation. Based on these results, a taxonomy of six levels of maturity is proposed—presence, coordination, functional reciprocity, mutual learning, epistemic co-construction, and institutional transformation—and mechanisms that favor bidirectionality are identified, including structured professional dialogue, joint action, hybrid spaces, shared objects of work, and the agency of the future teacher as a mediator of knowledge. Likewise, eight guiding dimensions are proposed for its evaluation: enabling conditions, relational symmetry, reciprocity of the flow of knowledge, mutual learning, co-construction, contributions, institutionalization and impact. The results show that the available evidence focuses on learning and contributions, while the demonstration of sustained and institutional impacts remains limited. The review thus provides a conceptual framework to understand bidirectionality as a process that can be classified and evaluated empirically, rather than as an inherent property of any university-school relationship.

This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit: