Weathering in cold regions: some thoughts and perspectives
- 1 December 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Progress in Physical Geography: Earth and Environment
- Vol. 26 (4) , 577-603
Abstract
Weathering in cold regions has primarily focused on the notion of ‘cold’, such that process and landform theory have generally used this both as the developmental criterion and as the outcome of palaeoenvironmental reconstructions based on landforms or sediments. As a result of this approach, the process focus in terms of weathering has been that mechanical processes predominate, with freeze-thaw weathering as the prime agent, and that chemical processes are temperature-inhibited, often to the point of nonoccurrence. Here a reconsideration of the whole conceptual framework of weathering in cold environments is undertaken. It is shown that, contrary to popular presentations, weathering, including chemical weathering, is not temperature-limited but rather is limited by moisture availability. Indeed, summer, and oft-times even winter, rock temperatures are more than adequate to support mechanical and chemical weathering if water is present. Where water is available it is clearly shown that chemical weathering can be a major component of the weathering regime. The argument is made that there is no zonality to cold environment weathering as none of the processes or process associations are unique to cold regions; indeed, many cold regions show similar weathering assemblages to those in hot arid regions. Process-form relationships are also questioned. The assumption of angularity with weathering in cold regions is questioned, all the more so as hot arid studies identify exactly the same angularity of debris form. Further, that all forms have to be angular is shown by field examples to be no more than an artefact of original unquestioning and oft-repeated assumptions, now over a century or more old. The argument is made that there is a strong need for the reconsideration of the nature of weathering in cold environments, that current theory should be questioned and challenged, and field observation undertaken within this revised frame of reference.Keywords
This publication has 87 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cold-climate shattering (1974 to 1993) of 200 glacial erratics on the exposed bottom of a recently drained arctic lake, Western Arctic coast, CanadaPermafrost and Periglacial Processes, 1999
- Nivation or cryoplanation: Different terms, same features?Polar Geography, 1998
- The periglacial environment of Plateau Mountain: Overview of current periglacial research1Polar Geography, 1997
- Aqueous geochemistry as an indicator of chemical weathering on southeastern Alexander Island, Antarctica1Polar Geography, 1997
- WEATHERING BY WETTING AND DRYING: SOME EXPERIMENTAL RESULTSEarth Surface Processes and Landforms, 1996
- Freeze‐thaw weathering: The cold region “Panacea”Polar Geography, 1995
- Ground ice conditions near Rea Point and on Sabine Peninsula, eastern Melville IslandCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1986
- The mechanism of repeated-segregation for the formation of thick layered ground iceCold Regions Science and Technology, 1983
- Disintegration of shale by cyclic wetting and drying and frost actionCanadian Journal of Earth Sciences, 1983
- Chemical Weathering at Low TemperaturesGeographical Review, 1949