In the weeks after the release of Todd Haynes's film inspired by ‘the music and many lives’ of Bob Dylan, I'm Not There (2007), a consensus emerged that of the seven different ‘Dylans’ portrayed on screen, it was Richard Gere's ‘Billy the Kid’ that was the least successful. Critics had qualms about it, on the Internet Movie Database fans consistently gave Gere low marks, and the press leaked accounts that distributor Harvey Weinstein had wanted the sequence cut from the film.1 Gere depicted Dylan from his Basement Tapes period, when the mercurial singer mined what Greil Marcus has called the ‘old, weird America’.2 Though opaque to many viewers, this section of Haynes's film has much to tell us about techniques for visualizing popular music, and challenges us to make fresh connections between...