‘What does it mean’, asks Keith Reader in the introduction to The Place de la Bastille: The Story of a Quartier (2011), ‘to write about a city?’ Keith’s erudite, eclectic and often very witty response was outlined in two of his final projects, this book on the Bastille and its companion volume, The Marais: The Story of a Quartier (2020). The role of place is evident throughout his work, whether on cinematic topographies or the multiple impacts of May ’68, or in a series of more confessional texts in which Keith was one of the first in French studies to reflect in personal terms on his engagement with the sites of Frenchness that underpinned his work. This article will show that Keith’s books on the Bastille and the Marais are the culmination of this reflection, grounding a lifelong engagement with the city and its cultural representations in a reflection on disciplinary identity and methodological practice.