Donor deferral policies for men who have sex with men
Authors:
- Mindy GoldmanMGMindy Goldman
- Sheila F. O’brienSOSheila F. O’brien
- 1 November 2016
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Current Opinion in Hematology
- Vol. 23 (6) , 568-572
Abstract
The review summarizes recent publications on the contentious issue of donor deferral criterion for men who have sex with men (MSM). Recent studies from the United States and China demonstrated that MSM is still a frequent risk factor for HIV-positive donors. Noncompliance is an important factor in the overall risk of HIV transmission but does not appear to be affected by the length of the deferral period. A major US study found a 2.6% noncompliance rate with the current indefinite deferral for MSM; similar or lower rates were found in other jurisdictions with shorter deferral periods. Several countries have had a defined deferral period of 1 year or 5 years in place long enough to determine that increases in HIV-positive cases predicted by modeling studies did not actually occur, suggesting that the assumptions made in these models are overly conservative. In summary, MSM eligibility policies are slowly changing around the world, with the US FDA now permitting a 1-year deferral. Transparency, involvement of stakeholders, and careful evaluation of risk and societal benefit should be part of future policy discussions on this issue.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cognitive evaluation of the AABBUniform Donor History QuestionnaireTransfusion, 2016
- Impact of a 5‐year deferral from blood donation for men who have sex with menTransfusion, 2015
- Saving lives, maintaining safety, and science‐based policy: qualitative interview findings from the Blood Donation Rules Opinion Study (Blood DROPS)Transfusion, 2015
- Blood donor deferral for men who have sex with men: the Blood Donation Rules Opinion Study (Blood DROPS)Transfusion, 2015
- Risk factors for retrovirus and hepatitis virus infections in accepted blood donorsTransfusion, 2014
- The proportion and trend of human immunodeficiency virus infections associated with men who have sex with men from Chinese voluntary blood donors: a systematic review and meta‐analysisTransfusion, 2014
- Sexual risk behaviour and donor deferral in EuropeVox Sanguinis, 2014
- Understanding noncompliance with selective donor deferral criteria for high‐risk behaviors in Australian blood donorsTransfusion, 2014
- Men Having Sex With Men Donor Deferral Risk Assessment: An Analysis Using Risk Management PrinciplesTransfusion Medicine Reviews, 2008
- The impact of male‐to‐male sexual experience on risk profiles of blood donorsTransfusion, 2005