Validity of Measured vs. Self-Reported Weight and Height and Practical Considerations for Enhancing Reliability in Clinical and Epidemiological Studies: A Systematic Review
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
Abstract
Self-reported measures of height and weight are often used in large epidemiological studies. However, concerns remain regarding the validity and reliability of these self-reported measures. The aim of this systematic review was to summarise and evaluate the comparative validity of measured and self-reported weight and height data and to recommend strategies to improve the reliability of self-reported-data collection across studies. This systematic review adopted the PRISMA guidelines. Four online sources, including PubMed, Medline, Google Scholar, and CINAHL, were utilised. A total of 17,800 articles were screened, and 10 studies were eligible to be included in the SLR based on the defined inclusion and exclusion criteria. The findings from the studies revealed good agreement between measured and self-reported weight and height based on intra-class correlation coefficient and Bland–Altman plots. Overall, measured weight and height had higher validity and reliability (ICC > 0.9; LOA < 1 SD). However, due to biases such as social pressure and self-esteem issues, women underreported their weight, while men overreported their height. In essence, self-reported measures remain valuable indicators to supplement the restricted direct anthropometric data, particularly in large-scale surveys. However, it is essential to address potential sources of bias.Keywords
Funding Information
- United Arab Emirates University (UAEU) (G00004295)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Building Machine Learning Models to Correct Self-Reported Anthropometric MeasuresJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2023
- Accuracy of self‐reported weight, height and body mass index among older people in JapanGeriatrics & Gerontology International, 2020
- Biases in self-reported height and weight measurements and their effects on modeling health outcomesSSM - Population Health, 2019
- Accuracy of body mass index measurements in community-dwelling older Japanese people based on self-reported anthropometric dataEuropean Geriatric Medicine, 2018
- Accuracy of self-reported weight in the Women’s Health InitiativePublic Health Nutrition, 2018
- Climate change as a polarizing cue: Framing effects on public support for low-carbon energy policiesGlobal Environmental Change, 2018
- Accuracy of Self-reported Weight in Hispanic/Latino Adults of the Hispanic Community Health Study/Study of LatinosEpidemiology, 2017
- Accuracy of on-line self-reported weights and heights by young adultsEuropean Journal of Public Health, 2017
- Determinant factors of the difference between self-reported weight and measured weight among JapaneseEnvironmental Health and Preventive Medicine, 2015
- Methods for knowledge synthesis: An overviewHeart & Lung, 2014