Another Nail in Which Coffin?

Authors:

Abstract
A recent Report “Volcanism in response to plate flexure” by N. Hirano et al. (8 Sept., p. [1426][1]) on small-volume volcanoes located far from plate boundaries and the related Perspective by M. McNutt “Another nail in the plume coffin?” (8 Sept., p. [1394][2]), which casts this contribution in the context of the ongoing plume controversy, have inspired us to comment. Hirano et al. begin with the claim that “[v]olcanism on Earth is known to occur in three tectonic settings: divergent plate boundaries…, convergent plate boundaries…, and hot spots,” followed by “Without the presence of a hot spot, new volcanism is not anticipated.” They go on to show that plate flexure can induce fracturing and small-volume volcanism, which is unlikely to be related to any “mantle plume.” The tenor of McNutt's Perspective is that this constitutes a victory in the ongoing battle against the hypothesis that volcanoes at hot spots are caused by jets of hot material (plumes) rising from the deep mantle (“It is thus with much kicking, dragging, and screaming that geoscientists are being brought to the realization that all might not be well with the concept of mantle plumes”). Actually, small-volume, within-plate volcanism isn't exactly news. There is a wealth of well-established knowledge about three types of within-plate, often alkalic volcanism that cannot directly be caused by deep mantle plumes: (i) tens of thousands of small volcanic seamounts ([1][3], [2][4]); (ii) the 1600-km-long chain of oceanic and continental volcanoes known as the Cameroon Line, which shows no detectable time progression of eruptions and has long been discussed as a “hot line,” not a plume ([3][5]); and (iii) volcanism associated with continental (and oceanic) rifts not related to plate boundaries. The discovery of another line of small alkalic seamounts not caused by a hot spot or a plume is neither new nor surprising. And the suggestion that this constitutes a “nail in the plume coffin” merely obfuscates the plume debate. The basic rules of geochemistry tell us that high enrichments of incompatible trace elements found in alkali basalts require low degrees of melting; such melts are hardly a surprise in regions of thick oceanic lithosphere. Whether the volcanism itself is triggered by a mantle plume or a fracture in the lithosphere is a separate question. The observation that fractures can and do trigger volcanism is not an argument against deepmantle plumes, any more than confirmation of mantle plumes, for example, through seismic tomography ([4][6]), could be an argument against fracture-related volcanism. The question of whether deep-mantle plumes exist is too important to our understanding of mantle dynamics to be addressed in this fashion. Instead, let's look at those volcanic features where a plume mechanism actually makes some geological sense and investigate those. We suspect that geochemistry will not deliver the silver bullet for proving or disproving plumes. Rather, we suspect that when the dust has settled over the mapping of plumes with seismic tomography, we will come to a consensus over the question of whether the Hawaiian hot spot, for example, is caused by a plume. Evidence from small seamounts seems completely irrelevant to this debate. So before we nail any more coffins, let's first be sure that there is a body to be buried. 1. 1.[↵][7]1. A. Zindler, 2. H. Staudigel, 3. R. Batiza , Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 70, 175 (1984). [OpenUrl][8] 2. 2.[↵][9]1. R. Batiza, 2. D. Vanko , J. Geophys. Res. 89, 11235 (1984). [OpenUrl][10] 3. 3.[↵][11]1. J. G. Fitton, 2. H. M. Dunlop , Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 72, 23 (1985). [OpenUrl][12] 4. 4.[↵][13]1. R. Montelli 2. et al. , Science 303, 338 (2004). [OpenUrl][14][Abstract/FREE Full Text][15] # Response {#article-title-2} We found young alkalic volcanoes, not older than 1 million years, on the edge of 135-million-year-old oceanic crust in the Northwest Pacific, where it is subducting into the Kuril and Japan trenches. These volcanoes are closely associated with the occurrence of extensional cracks in the flexed parts of the subducting Pacific Plate, allowing small amounts of partial melts to find their way to Earth's surface from the shallow asthenosphere. Because of their small volume, we named these volcanoes petit spots, which should not be confused with hot spot volcanism. Hofmann and Hart fittingly note that McNutt's Perspective stretches her interpretation of this new type of within-plate volcanism too thin, by linking it to the heated debate on the existence of mantle plumes and the formation of the major hot spot trails, like Hawaii ([1][16], [2][17]). We agree with Hofmann and Hart that the discussion of the petit spot model should be divorced from the ongoing mantle plume debate. Instead, we emphasize the unique tectonic settings in which the petit spot volcanoes are formed. Other types of non-plume-related volcanism have been recognized to exist close to the midocean spreading centers, in continental rifts, and maybe in some seamount trails, like the Cameroon Line. However, none of these volcanoes were formed at locations far away from spreading centers, hot spots, or, more generally, areas of thermal upwelling. Whereas small off-axis seamounts ([3][18]–[5][19]) are easily explained by the faulting and thermal contraction of juvenile oceanic crust during seafloor spreading, the formation of young volcanoes on oceanic crust older than 100 million years is rather uncommon and remained undiscovered until we recognized the petit spots on the oldest part of the Pacific Plate. These volcanoes have geochemical signatures that are characterized by highly alkaline major element compositions, highly enriched incompatible elements, and degassed noble gas isotope ratios. These characteristics suggest a low degree of partial melting in...

This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit: