Accounting for Technical, Ethical, and Political Factors in Priority Setting
Open Access
- 2 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Health Systems & Reform
- Vol. 2 (1) , 51-60
Abstract
—This article investigates two cases of priority setting to explore how, in addition to technical considerations, ethical and political factors shape the allocation of health resources. First, we discuss how Thai authorities adjudicated a coverage decision for HLA-B*1502 screening, which meets the national cost-effectiveness threshold for only some of the conditions it can detect. Second, we consider England's Cancer Drugs Fund to investigate the interplay of technical decision making and political reality. Our findings suggest four concluding observations for policy makers and others considering priority-setting processes. First, we observe that different methods can produce conflicting recommendations, which makes priority setting very complex. Second, we suggest that robust processes for generating and weighing political, ethical, and technical evidence are essential because there is no absolute standard by which resource allocation decisions can be made. Third, priority setting is inherently political, and improving its technical and ethical validity means constructing political importance for these other factors. Fourth, we argue that transparency in the trade-offs required to set priorities is important ethically and can help build support politically.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Economic evaluation ofHLA‐B*15:02 screening for carbamazepine‐induced severe adverse drug reactions inThailandEpilepsia, 2013
- Using stakeholder analysis to support moves towards universal coverage: lessons from the SHIELD projectHealth Policy and Planning, 2012
- The Situationist Critique and Early Confucian Virtue EthicsEthics, 2011
- Clinical priority settingBMJ, 2008
- National Institute for Clinical Excellence and its value judgmentsBMJ, 2004
- The second phase of priority settingGoodbye to the simple solutions: the second phase of priority setting in health careFairness as a problem of love and the heart: a clinician's perspective on priority settingIsrael's basic basket of health services: the importance of being explicitly implicitBMJ, 1998
- The politics of agenda setting in international health: Child health versus adult health in developing countriesJournal of International Development, 1995
- The politics of health sector reform in developing countries: three cases of pharmaceutical policyHealth Policy, 1995
- Dimensions of rationing: who should do what?BMJ, 1993
- Ethics and Efficiency in the Provision of Health CareRoyal Institute of Philosophy Lecture Series, 1988