What Did Weierstrass Really Define? The Cognitive Structure of Natural and ∊-δ Continuity
Author:
- Rafael E. NunezRNRafael E. Nunez
- 1 September 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Mathematical Cognition
- Vol. 4 (2) , 85-101
Abstract
The cognitive science of mathematics is the study of mathematical ideas from the perspective of research on our largely unconscious everyday conceptual systems as they are embodied in the human brain. A major result is that most everyday abstract ideas are metaphorical in nature—that is, they involve inference-preserving mappings from one conceptual domain to another. Many mathematical ideas are metaphorical in this respect, as when we conceptualise numbers metaphorically as points on a line, or when we conceptualise lines metaphorically as sets of points. The concept of ∊-δ continuity is metaphorical as well. In everyday thought, (natural) continuity is understood in terms of a trajectory of motion, as it was in mathematics until the late nineteenth century. From a cognitive perspective, what Dedekind and Weierstrass really did was to introduce new metaphors for natural continuity. That is, they conceptualised continuity for lines and for functions in terms of two new and radically different concepts: gaplessness for lines, and preservation of closeness for functions. But the mathematical community has incorrectly seen Weierstrass as having done something different: defining the essence of the concept of continuity. This mistake has confused generations of mathematics students and has led to a misleading, counterintuitive, and cognitively untenable view of what continuity is.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fictive Motion in Language and "Ception"1996
- The Human Semantic Potential1996
- The contemporary theory of metaphor1993
- The Embodied Mind1991
- From Etymology to Pragmatics1990
- More than Cool Reason1989
- The Body in the Mind1987
- Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things1987
- Concept image and concept definition in mathematics with particular reference to limits and continuityEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1981
- On the arithmetization of mathematicsBulletin of the American Mathematical Society, 1899