Representation Rethought: On Trustees, Delegates, and Gyroscopes in the Study of Political Representation and Democracy
Top Cited Papers
- 1 May 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Political Science Review
- Vol. 103 (2) , 214-230
Abstract
The trustee/delegate problem purportedly expresses how closely a representative's votes in the legislature should correspond to their constituents' preferences. In this article, I argue that the usual formulation of this debate collapses three distinctions—aims, source of judgment, andresponsiveness—and thus obscures the underlying complexity of the phenomenon. Given its tripartite formulation, the collapse of these distinctions into a binary “trustee/delegate” formulation obscures a more complex political landscape with eight—rather than two—ideal types. Furthermore, once unpacked, we can see that the distinctions operate entirely independent of the location of authority, leading to the seemingly paradoxicalinstructedtrustees andindependentdelegates. I also claim that the three distinctions apply to any decision maker, and thus, the attribution of this problem as distinctive of democratic political representation is an important overstatement. The article thus contributes to a more general theory of political representation that can be applied in nonelectoral and nondemocratic contexts increasingly relevant to global politics.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Who Loses in American Democracy? A Count of Votes Demonstrates the Limited Representation of African AmericansAmerican Political Science Review, 2009
- The Good Representative2007
- Towards a General Theory of Political RepresentationThe Journal of Politics, 2006
- Rethinking Redistricting: How Drawing Uncompetitive Districts Eliminates Gerrymanders, Enhances Representation, and Improves Attitudes toward CongressPS: Political Science & Politics, 2006
- Can Justice Be Based on Consent?*Journal of Political Philosophy, 2004
- Rethinking RepresentationAmerican Political Science Review, 2003
- Democracy, Accountability, and Representation1999
- Electoral Accountability and the Control of Politicians: Selecting Good Types versus Sanctioning Poor Performance1999
- Enhancing Democracy Through Legislative RedistrictingAmerican Political Science Review, 1994
- John Locke Two Treatises of Government1988