Evaluative Schemas and the Mediating Role of Critics
- 1 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 23 (1) , 83-97
Abstract
How do critics enable producers and consumers to come to mutually agreeable terms of trade? We propose that critics offer more guidance to those who set prices when their quality assessments are structured by clearer evaluative schemas. Schema clarity enables producers to accurately anticipate the quality assessments that critics will disseminate to the market. This allows their posted prices to center more faithfully on prevailing conceptions of quality. We then argue that the position of a producer within the market's social structure—in terms of its prior coverage, reputation, and niche width—influences the degree to which it is guided by clear evaluative schemas. We test these predictions in the market for U.S. wines. After elaborating a novel approach to inferring the clarity of evaluative schemas within different varietal categories, we demonstrate that list prices are less variable around expected levels when the schemas used to evaluate quality are clearer. Moreover, this effect is stronger among more relevant and more focused producers in each category.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Categorical contrast and audience appeal: niche width and critical success in winemakingIndustrial and Corporate Change, 2010
- In the Bud? Disk Array Producers as a (Possibly) Emergent Organizational FormAdministrative Science Quarterly, 2003
- The Categorical Imperative: Securities Analysts and the Illegitimacy DiscountAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1999
- Brands' quality levels, prices, and advertising outlays: empirical evidence on signals and information costsInternational Journal of Industrial Organization, 1996
- Market Uncertainty and the Social Character of Economic ExchangeAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1994
- Critics and Publics: Cultural Mediation in Highbrow and Popular Performing ArtsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1991
- Professional Ideologies and Patterns of "Gatekeeping": Evaluation and Judgment Within Two Art WorldsSocial Forces, 1988
- Variance Function EstimationJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1987
- Where Do Markets Come From?American Journal of Sociology, 1981
- Measurement of DiversityNature, 1949