A study of Chinese medical students’ communication pattern in delivering bad news: an ethnographic discourse analysis approach
Author:
Open Access
- 19 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
Background: Breaking bad news is inevitable for prospective doctors, it is important for medical students to learn how to humanely communicate devastating news to patients. This study explores the discourse strategies used by Chinese medical students when conducting critical conversations via role-play scenarios. Methods: Fifty Year-6 medical students attending the ‘Serious Illness Communication Module’ were recruited from a local medical school in Hong Kong. They were asked to participate voluntarily in two role-play scenarios requiring them to break bad news to a simulated patient in Cantonese. The verbal interactions were video-recorded and analysed using an ethnographic discourse approach to unpack the quality of the observed interaction sequences and identify the discourse strategies strategically used by the medical students to overcome any communication breakdowns (e.g. linguistic expressions conveying diagnoses) and show empathy to patients. Results: Six discourse strategies for delivering bad news were identified in the Chinese context: (1) placing great emphasis on patients’ emotional needs; (2) informing patients with a balanced focus on medical and emotional needs; (3) directing patients’ attention to treatment options; (4) acknowledging concerns about dying patients’ physical discomfort and wishes; (5) directing bad news disclosure to patients; and (6) addressing the family expectations of patients. The majority of the Chinese medical students in this study used a patient-oriented approach to cater to the patients’ emotional and physical needs. They also often informed and acknowledged the patients’ family members. Conclusions: When delivering bad news, medical students should be equipped with discourse strategies that effectively balance interpersonal communication with the communication of medical expertise, which is integral to ensuring patients’ participation, their understanding and satisfaction with their clinicians. This is in accordance with the existing communication frameworks for critical conversation and demonstrates awareness of the needs in the Chinese context. However, some students demonstrated poor sensitivity to non-verbal cues, such as tone, manners and attitude. Thus, more training using a culturally appropriate model of communication for critical conversation should be promoted.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Voice analysis during bad news discussion in oncology: reduced pitch, decreased speaking rate, and nonverbal communication of empathySupportive Care in Cancer, 2011
- Creating COMFORT: A Communication-based model for Breaking Bad NewsCommunication Education, 2010
- The importance of vocal affect to bimodal processing of emotion: Implications for individuals with traumatic brain injuryJournal of Communication Disorders, 2009
- Cancer information disclosure in different cultural contextsSupportive Care in Cancer, 2004
- Medical residents’ first clearly remembered experiences of giving bad newsJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2002
- Awareness of Dying: An Experience of Chinese Patients with Terminal CancerOMEGA - Journal of Death and Dying, 2001
- Chinese seniors’ perspectives on end-of-life decisionsSocial Science & Medicine, 2001
- The Calgary—Cambridge Referenced Observation Guides: an aid to defining the curriculum and organizing the teaching in communication training programmesMedical Education, 1996
- Giving sad and bad newsThe Lancet, 1993
- Breaking bad news: why is it still so difficult?BMJ, 1984