Discourse, justification and critique: towards a legitimate digital copyright regime?
Open Access
- 6 January 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Cultural Policy
- p. 1-18
Abstract
Digitization and the internet have posed an acute economic challenge to rights holders in the cultural industries. Faced with a threat to their form of capital accumulation from copyright infringement, rights holders have used discourse strategically in order to try and legitimate and strengthen their position in the digital copyright debate with governments and media users. In so doing, they have appealed to general justificatory principles – about what is good, right, and just – that provide some scope for opposition and critique, as other groups contest their interpretation of these principles and the evidence used to support them. In this article, we address the relative lack of academic attention paid to the role of discourse in copyright debates by analysing user-directed marketing campaigns and submissions to UK government policy consultations. We show how legitimacy claims are justified and critiqued, and conclude that amid these debates rests some hope of achieving a more legitimate policy resolution to the copyright wars – or at least the possibility of beginning a more constructive dialogue.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Consumers, crime and the downloading of musicPrometheus, 2010
- The rise of ‘user creativity’ – Web 2.0 and a new challenge for copyright law and cultural policyInternational Journal of Cultural Policy, 2010
- `China Who Makes and Fakes'Theory, Culture & Society, 2008
- CAPTURING FAIR USE FOR THE YOUTUBE GENERATION: The Digital Rights Movement, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the user-centered framing of fair useInformation, Communication & Society, 2008
- The rhetorics and myths of anti-piracy campaigns: criminalization, moral pedagogy and capitalist property relations in the classroomNew Media & Society, 2008
- Digital Sampling and Cultural InequalitySocial & Legal Studies, 2006
- Mapping Film Piracy in ChinaTheory, Culture & Society, 2003
- Understanding the new management ideology: a transdisciplinary contribution from critical discourse analysis and new sociology of capitalismDiscourse & Society, 2002
- Copyright, risk and the artist: An economic approach to policy for artistsInternational Journal of Cultural Policy, 1999
- Copyright, Culture and Private PowerPrometheus, 1998