Estimation of Heterogeneous Within-Herd Variance Components Using Empirical Bayes Methods: A Simulation Study
Authors:
- D. GianolaDGD. Gianola
Open Access
- 1 October 1992
- journal article
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 75 (10) , 2824-2833
Abstract
Genetic evaluation using BLUP can accommodate heterogeneous variances if the necessary variance components are known; this may require estimation of variance components within each heterogeneous subclass. Properties of sire and residual variance estimates obtained by an empirical Bayes approach, which combines within-herd and prior estimates, were examined via simulation. Prior estimates were obtained using REML across herds, as if variances were homogeneous. Convergence was improved by incorporation of prior information such that variance component estimates could be obtained in within-herd situations for which a REML algorithm failed to converge. Accuracy of sire variance estimates was greatest when both within-herd and prior information were used, but improvement in accuracy of residual variance estimates associated with incorporation of prior information was minimal. Correlations between sires' standardized true transmitting abilities and PTA that used empirical Bayes variance estimates were larger than those obtained when heterogeneity was ignored. Proportions of sires selected, based on standardized PTA, from environments with differing genetic and residual variances became more uniform as the relative weight placed on within-herd data in variance estimation increased. Thus, useful variance component estimates can be obtained within individual herds by using empirical Bayes methods with across-herd estimates as prior information; this may allow prediction of breeding values that are less influenced by heterogeneous variances.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Marginal likelihood and Bayesian approaches to the analysis of heterogeneous residual variances in mixed linear Gaussian modelsComputational Statistics & Data Analysis, 1992
- Heterogeneous Within-Herd Variance. 1. Genetic Parameters for First and Second Lactation Milk Yields of Grade Holstein CowsJournal of Dairy Science, 1990
- A Method for Assessing Extent and Sources of Heterogeneity of Residual Variances in Mixed Linear ModelsJournal of Dairy Science, 1990
- Adjustment for Heterogeneity of Variances by Herd Production Level in Dairy Cow and Sire EvaluationJournal of Dairy Science, 1990
- Effect of Heterogeneity of Variance on Dairy Sire EvaluationJournal of Dairy Science, 1988
- Prediction of Daughter's Performance from Dam's Cow Index Adjusted for Within-Herd VarianceJournal of Dairy Science, 1988
- Potential Bias in Genetic Evaluations from Differences in Variation Within HerdsJournal of Dairy Science, 1987
- Genetic Parameters for First Lactation Milk Yields at Three Levels of Herd ProductionJournal of Dairy Science, 1987
- On selection criteria and estimation of parameters when the variance is heterogeneousTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 1986
- On selection among groups with heterogeneous varianceAnimal Science, 1984