How to deal with the criterion of severe mental distress for late termination of pregnancy? A scoping literature review and a content analysis of clinical ethics consultations
Authors:
Open Access
- 9 April 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 26 (1) , 1-9
Abstract
The issue of late termination of pregnancy (abortion after a certain gestational age, depending on different definitions) is a topic of intense debate among healthcare professionals and the public, as it involves balancing the divergent interests and needs of the pregnant person and the foetus. Some jurisdictions recognize severe mental distress as a valid criterion for allowing late termination of pregnancy. However, the unavailability of a clear definition presents challenges in clinical practice. A scoping literature review was conducted to examine how the criterion of severe mental distress is operationalised in the context of late termination of pregnancy. In addition, we conducted a qualitative content analysis of clinical ethics consultation reports dealing with requests for late termination of pregnancy in a Swiss university hospital. The scoping review of the literature yielded that 23 publications distributed worldwide were relevant to the question. Regarding the concept of severe mental distress, there is no uniform terminology. The indication for abortion is referred to as psychiatric, psychosocial, or sociomedical indication, or maternal emergency. Various criteria are mentioned that can contribute to categorising a condition as a severe mental crisis to varying degrees, including age, psychiatric illnesses, psychological conditions, foetal malformations, socio-economic conditions, or criminological circumstances. The qualitative content analysis of 20 clinical ethics consultation reports revealed a range of ethical challenges that arise in clinical practice, namely how the risk of severe mental distress can be assessed, whether the termination of pregnancy is suitable to avert the distress, and whether the termination of pregnancy is proportionate. We identified several recurring criteria that require clarification to aid decision making, such as whether treatment options and alternatives have been adequately discussed and presented, whether the request is consistent and enduring, and whether there are causes of severe mental distress that could be eliminated otherwise. For jurisdictions that allow late-term abortion based on severe mental distress, we propose a set of guiding questions to support healthcare professionals engaging in careful decision making.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Basel
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Kommentar I zum Fall: „Seelische Notlage und später Schwangerschaftsabbruch“Ethik in der Medizin, 2023
- Medical Termination Of Pregnancy For Psychosocial ReasonsJournal of Gynecology Obstetrics and Human Reproduction, 2021
- Menschenwürde und Spätabbruch2012
- The “Psychiatric Masquerade”: The Mental Health Exception in New Zealand Abortion LawFeminist Legal Studies, 2010
- Legal abortion for mental health indicationsInternational Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics, 2006
- Reasons for induced abortion and their relation to women's emotional distress: a prospective, two-year follow-up studyGeneral Hospital Psychiatry, 2005
- The role of patients/family members in the hospital ethics committee's review and deliberationsHEC Forum, 1990
- Psychiatric Indications or Psychiatric Justification of Therapeutic Abortion?Archives of General Psychiatry, 1970
- Psychiatric indications for the termination of pregnancyJournal of Psychosomatic Research, 1966
- Geburtenregelung und Schwangerschafts-unterbrechung in psychiatrischer SichtInternational Journal of Public Health, 1962