Accelerating the diffusion of community-based home charging stations is a promising strategy to address the inequitable accessibility of community charging. Policymakers can use monetary incentives, such as higher charging price premiums, or non-monetary incentives, such as establishing better neighborhood relationships, improving members’ sense of community belonging, or deepening their social connections, to achieve this goal. However, policymakers must often make trade-offs because monetary incentives typically involve substantial economic input. To explore these trade-offs, we developed an agent-based simulation model and found that a 15% increase in the number of random links among home charging station owners can replace a 10% increase in the charging price premium. Adding an average of four ties among agents or doubling the sense of community belonging can yield equivalent substitution effects. Based on these findings, policy recommendations are provided on how to trade-off between them.