It’s Complicated: Maillard, Umami and Flavor Complexity Are Not Key Factors in Liking of Gray Pea Burgers in a Real Consumption Context
Open Access
Abstract
Literature suggests that umami, Maillard reaction, and flavor complexity could contribute to sensorial acceptability of plant-based alternatives, but that was yet to be tested. Two field studies with 612 paying customers evaluating a complete meal were conducted in an operating restaurant in Sweden. In the first study, a gray pea burger (Control) was compared to burgers with added monosodium glutamate (MSG) (Umami), grilled (Maillard), or both grilled and added MSG (Complex). In the second study, a simplified gray pea burger (Control 2) was compared to a grilled burger with MSG and aromatics (Complex 2). Check-all-that-apply (CATA) tests show that participants perceived sensory differences between the samples, but their effects in hedonic ratings were inconclusive; only the Maillard sample was significantly more liked than Control and Complex burgers in Study 1. Although limited to their variables and context, these two experiments indicate that umami, Maillard reaction, and complexity, per se, are not key factors to improve liking and willingness to buy (WTB) of plant-based dishes. These results suggest that rather than trying to emulate sensory characteristics considered associated with meat, future research could prioritize addressing cultural barriers to vegetarian food.Keywords
Funding Information
- Swedish Research Council for Sustainable Development (2020–02843)
- Tillväxtverket (20361373)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- How can consumer science help the foodservice industry replace meat? A critical reviewAppetite, 2025
- The role of pulses in improving human health: A reviewLegume Science, 2022
- Meat tastes good, legumes are healthy and meat substitutes are still strange - The practice of protein consumption among Swedish consumersAppetite, 2022
- Sensory acceptability of new plant protein meat substitutesFood Quality and Preference, 2022
- A multi-national comparison of meat eaters' attitudes and expectations for burgers containing beef, pea or algae proteinFood Quality and Preference, 2021
- Sensory complexity and its influence on hedonic responses: A systematic review of applications in food and beveragesFood Quality and Preference, 2019
- Rationalizing meat consumption. The 4NsAppetite, 2015
- Comparison of three sensory profiling methods based on consumer perception: CATA, CATA with intensity and Napping®Food Quality and Preference, 2014
- Effect of sensory education on food preferences in childrenFood Quality and Preference, 2010
- Effects of complexity and intensity on sensory specific satiety and food acceptance after repeated consumptionFood Quality and Preference, 2008