Developing agency through experiences of misalignment: A path to becoming a physician
Open Access
- 5 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
Abstract
Introduction: How medical students respond to the dissonance that can result from misalignments between personal values and the norms and values of the profession informs their evolving professional identities. But to what extent do medical students have agency to respond intentionally to these experiences? While current literature focuses primarily on agentic constraints (e.g., hierarchy), how medical students enact agency when they perceive the expectations of the clinical environment to be negatively aligned with their own values remains underexplored. This study examines the following research questions: (1) How do medical students perceive their agency when experiencing misalignment between their personal values and the norms and values of the clinical setting? and (2) How do medical students perceive their experiences of agency in the face of misalignment as contributing to their professional identity formation (PIF)? Methods: This study used interpretive description methodology, with social cognitive theory as a primary theoretical framework. Semi‐structured interviews ( n = 16) were conducted with third‐ and fourth‐year medical students at McGill University, using rich pictures as an elicitation technique. Interpretive themes were generated iteratively and inductively. Results: Participants reported that agency evolved over time and was shaped by experiences of misalignment. In situations of negative misalignment, the enactment of agency was described as shaped by emotional responses, involving dynamic, often deliberate judgements that weighed internal and external factors. Participants' accounts further suggested that enacting agency in these moments may have informed their future capacity for agency and their PIF. Discussion: This study highlighted how developing and enacting agency in response to misalignment contributes to PIF. By implementing strategies to foster agency, such as guiding reflection on the emotions associated with misalignment, medical educators may be better positioned to help students engage more meaningfully in becoming the physicians they hope to become.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moving Beyond Static, Individualistic Approaches to Agency: Theories of Agency for Medical Education Researchers: AMEE Guide No. 177Medical Teacher, 2025
- Reframing professional identity through navigating tensions during residency: A qualitative studyPerspectives on Medical Education, 2022
- Negotiating professional identity formation in medicine as an ‘outsider’: The experience of professionalization for minoritized medical studentsSSM - Qualitative Research in Health, 2021
- How Attendings Can Help Residents Navigate Moral Distress: A Qualitative StudyAcademic Pediatrics, 2021
- What Role Should Resistance Play in Training Health Professionals?Academic Medicine, 2021
- Moral Distress in Pediatric Residents and Pediatric Hospitalists: Sources and Association With BurnoutAcademic Pediatrics, 2020
- Clinical Teachers’ Perceptions of Their Role in Professional Identity FormationAcademic Medicine, 2020
- Who Am I, and Who Do I Strive to Be? Applying a Theory of Self-Conscious Emotions to Medical EducationAcademic Medicine, 2018
- Stereotype Vulnerability Scale--Modified for Ethnicity Stereotypes2016
- A Schematic Representation of the Professional Identity Formation and Socialization of Medical Students and ResidentsAcademic Medicine, 2015