Non-target detections change the interpretation of environmental DNA communities
Authors:
- Megan R. ShafferMSMegan R. Shaffer
- Elizabeth Andruszkiewicz AllanEAElizabeth Andruszkiewicz Allan
- Ryan P. KellyRKRyan P. Kelly
- Nicolaus G. AdamsNANicolaus G. Adams
- Stephanie K. MooreSMStephanie K. Moore
- Elizabeth BrassealeEBElizabeth Brasseale
- Pedro F. P. Brandão‐DiasPBPedro F. P. Brandão‐Dias
- Olivia M. ScottOSOlivia M. Scott
- Andrew O. SheltonASAndrew O. Shelton
- Kim M. ParsonsKPKim M. Parsons
Open Access
- 2 June 2026
- journal article
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in Metabarcoding and Metagenomics
- Vol. 10, e174467
Abstract
Environmental DNA (eDNA) samples capture mixtures of DNA from a wide range of organisms and often yield metabarcoding datasets that include taxa beyond the intended scope of the primer set used. The presence of this non-target DNA (termed “molecular bycatch”) can make it difficult to interpret trends in the primary targets. Here, we present an example in which including non-target detections alters the ecological interpretation of a metabarcoding time series and highlight a quantitative approach that can account for molecular bycatch in a biologically meaningful way. We collected high-resolution temporal samples from an estuary (Hood Canal, Washington, USA), using a surface-stationed autonomous sampler over a 48-hour period. We metabarcoded samples with a primer set that targets fish, but also amplifies (non-target) marine mammals with lower efficiency. We then transformed sequence read proportions into absolute DNA concentrations using a mock community–based bias correction and single-species concentrations via droplet digital PCR (ddPCR). We found that non-target mammals were substantially under-represented in the raw metabarcoding data relative to their biased-corrected proportions. Cross-validation of this quantitative metabarcoding approach showed that predicted DNA concentrations closely matched independent ddPCR measurements for total 12S DNA and two single-species concentrations (Atlantic bottlenose dolphin and Pacific herring) in both mock communities and environmental samples. After estimating absolute species concentrations for all species, we revealed species-specific patterns that were not apparent in the observed read counts alone. Our results underscore the importance of correcting for species-specific amplification bias when evaluating community composition from metabarcoding data, particularly in the context of non-target detections.Keywords
Funding Information
- Office of Naval Research
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gone in a Splash? Temporal Dynamics of Flukeprint Environmental DNA (eDNA) Detection for Common Coastal Northeast Pacific Cetacean SpeciesEnvironmental DNA, 2025
- Validation of Environmental DNA for Estimating Proportional and Absolute BiomassEnvironmental DNA, 2024
- Quantifying impacts of an environmental intervention using environmental DNAEcological Applications, 2023
- Using qPCR of environmental DNA (eDNA) to estimate the biomass of juvenile Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.)Environmental DNA, 2023
- Toward quantitative metabarcodingEcology, 2022
- 12S gene metabarcoding with DNA standard quantifies marine bony fish environmental DNA, identifies threshold for reproducible detection, and overcomes distortion due to amplification of non‐fish DNAEnvironmental DNA, 2022
- Strong positive relationships between eDNA concentrations and biomass in juvenile and adult pike (Esox lucius) under controlled conditions: Implications for monitoringEnvironmental DNA, 2022
- Environmental DNA shedding and decay rates from diverse animal forms and thermal regimesEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Comparing eDNA metabarcoding and species collection for documenting Arctic metazoan biodiversityEnvironmental DNA, 2019
- Effect of water temperature and fish biomass on environmental DNA shedding, degradation, and size distributionEcology and Evolution, 2019