The Silent Battle on the Budget: The Effect of Centralized Indexing on Collection Analysis in Primo and EBSCO
- 6 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Collection Management
- Vol. 46 (1) , 3-13
Abstract
Significant cuts to the collections budget and a fire in the main library at Kansas State University transitioned the Libraries toward an increased focus upon electronic resources management. As electronic resource discovery continues to be hampered by market competition between Ex Libris and EBSCO library vendors, difficulties were identified in obtaining accurate usage statistics for resource renewal reviews, particularly EBSCO products. Kansas State University Libraries use the ALMA URM in combination with Primo discovery service, which experiences known resolver complications when paired with EBSCO resources. Technical services librarians and information technology staff tested several workarounds, but the question remains whether any proposed resolutions can be truly effective in avoiding collection usage biases and analytical discrepancies, resulting from exclusive indexing. Crunching the numbers, monetarily and analytically, the Ex Libris and EBSCO rivalry is an onerous battle on the budget and resource renewal process.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Whirlwind of Change Data: How Libraries and Vendors Translate Data Into Discovery and AccessSerials Review, 2019
- Resource Management in a Time of Fiscal Scarcity: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Assessment for Journal Package CancellationsThe Serials Librarian, 2019
- Web-Scale Discovery Services Retrieve Relevant Results in Health Sciences Topics Including MEDLINE ContentEvidence Based Library and Information Practice, 2017
- Impact of a Discovery System on Interlibrary LoanCollege and Research Libraries, 2016
- Comparison of three web-scale discovery services for health sciences researchJournal of the Medical Library Association, 2016
- Editorial Board Thoughts: Library Analytics and Patron PrivacyInformation Technology and Libraries, 2015
- Evaluating Web-Scale Discovery Services: A Step-by-Step GuideInformation Technology and Libraries, 2015
- The Importance of Identifying and Accommodating E-Resource Usage Data for the Presence of Outliers. The Negative Impacts of Inaccurate E-Journal Usage Data.Information Technology and Libraries, 2014