Racial and Ethnic Bias in Letters of Recommendation in Academic Medicine: A Systematic Review
- 8 March 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 99 (9) , 1032-1037
Abstract
Purpose: Letters of recommendations (LORs) are key components of academic medicine applications. Given that bias against students and trainees underrepresented in medicine (UIM) has been demonstrated across assessment, achievement, and advancement domains, the authors reviewed studies on LORs to assess racial, ethnic, and UIM differences in LORs. Standardized LORs (SLORs), an increasingly common form of LORs, were also assessed for racial and ethnic differences. Method: A systematic review was conducted for English-language studies that assessed racial or ethnic differences in LORs in academic medicine published from database inception to July 16, 2023. Studies evaluating SLORs underwent data abstraction to evaluate their impact on the given race or ethnicity comparison and outcome variables. Results: Twenty-three studies describing 19,012 applicants and 41,925 LORs were included. Nineteen studies (82.6%) assessed LORs for residency, 4 (17.4%) assessed LORs for fellowship, and none evaluated employment or promotion. Fifteen of 17 studies (88.2%) assessing linguistic differences reported a significant difference in a particular race or ethnicity comparison. Of the 7 studies assessing agentic language (e.g., “strong,” “confident”), 1 study found fewer agentic terms used for Black and Latinx applicants, and 1 study reported higher agency scores for Asian applicants and applicants of races other than White. There were mixed results for the use of communal and grindstone language in UIM and non-UIM comparisons. Among 6 studies, 4 (66.7%) reported that standout language (e.g., “exceptional,” “outstanding”) was less likely to be ascribed to UIM applicants. Doubt-raising language was more frequently used for UIM trainees. When SLORs and unstructured LORs were compared, fewer linguistic differences were found in SLORs. Conclusions: There is a moderate bias against UIM candidates in the domains of linguistic differences, doubt-raising language, and topics discussed in LORs, which has implications for perceptions of competence and ability in the high-stakes residency and fellowship application process.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Words Used in Letters of Recommendation for Pediatric Residency Applicants: Demographic Differences and Impact on InterviewsAcademic Pediatrics, 2023
- The Context of “Confidence”: Analyzing the Term Confidence in Resident EvaluationsJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2022
- Association of Mistreatment and Discrimination With Medical School AttritionJAMA Pediatrics, 2022
- Do gender and racial differences exist in letters of recommendation for obstetrics and gynecology residency applicants?American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2021
- Racial and Gender Discrimination in Hand Surgery Letters of RecommendationThe Journal of Hand Surgery, 2021
- Ethnic/Racial Bias in Medical School Performance Evaluation of General Surgery Residency ApplicantsJournal of Surgical Education, 2021
- Do male chairs of surgery have implicit gender bias in the residency application process?The American Journal of Surgery, 2021
- Linguistic Biases in Letters of Recommendation for Radiation Oncology Residency Applicants from 2015 to 2019Journal of Cancer Education, 2020
- Gender and Racial Bias in Radiology Residency Letters of RecommendationJournal of the American College of Radiology, 2020
- Racial Disparities in Medical Student Membership in the Alpha Omega Alpha Honor SocietyJAMA Internal Medicine, 2017