We study a major cyberattack at a large omnichannel grocery retailer that triggered a one-week shutdown of its online store and a corporate data breach. Using high-frequency panel data on more than 20,000 loyalty customers over 2019 and 2022, we implement a within-customer difference-indifferences design. Over the 13-week post-attack window, online transactions and online revenue both declined by approximately 10% relative to the counterfactual, with effects persisting across short-, medium-, and long-term horizons and no evidence of recovery. This contrasts with firm-level event studies, which show only short-term market reactions. The offline channel provided limited mitigation of the effects. Customers primarily substituted for alternative retailers rather than reallocating purchases within the firm, resulting in a net revenue decline for our industry partner. Effects were heterogeneous and customers with a higher concentration of online purchases, higher patronage (greater online purchase frequency and spending), and subscription ties exhibited greater shopping resilience, whereas customers with predictable shopping patterns who likely would have shopped during the affected period (and thus directly experienced the outage) were more prone to churn. This concentration of the effect among customers most likely to have been directly affected by the outage is more consistent with a substitution mechanism triggered by the disruption itself than with a generalised trust-loss interpretation, which would predict a similar response across informed customers regardless of their individual exposure to the disruption window.